Rank The Postseason Quarterbacks

[ROH522155]

1. Aaron Rodgers

2. Tom Brady

3. Peyton Manning

4. Ben Roethlisberger

5. Andrew Luck

6. Joe Flacco

7. Tony Romo

8. Russell Wilson

9. Cam Newton

10. Matthew Stafford

11. Andy Dalton

12. Ryan Lindley

 

[Pats]

Andy dalton smashes everyone and ryan lindley a close second.

Now that i'm actually being serious :

1. Brady
2.Rodgers
3.Berger
4.Flacco (int he playoffs hes really good)
5.Wilson
6.Manning
7.Romo
8.Luck
9.Newton
10.Stafford
11.Dalton
12.Lindley

[beanfigger]

1. Aaron Rodgers

2. Tom Brady

3. Peyton Manning

4. Ben Roethlisberger

5. Andrew Luck

6. Joe Flacco

7. Tony Romo

8. Russell Wilson

9. Cam Newton

10. Matthew Stafford

11. Andy Dalton

12. Ryan Lindley

I agree with your groups of four. My order might be different in each, but same names in top four, second four, third four.

[Ravenslifer]

1. Aaron Rodgers

2. Tom Brady

3. Peyton Manning

4. Ben Roethlisberger

5. Andrew Luck

6. Joe Flacco

7. Tony Romo

8. Russell Wilson

9. Cam Newton

10. Matthew Stafford

11. Andy Dalton

12. Ryan Lindley

 

I dont' know if postseason Manning and postseason Luck deserve that high of a ranking - in his last 2 postseason losses Manning has 2 picks each, and Andrew Luck had 7 picks in 2 games last year.  Honestly I'd put Joe and Wilson above both, and actually Romo is kind of an unknown IMO because he hasn't been to the postseason in 5 years.

[Inqui]

I dont' know if postseason Manning and postseason Luck deserve that high of a ranking - in his last 2 postseason losses Manning has 2 picks each, and Andrew Luck had 7 picks in 2 games last year.  Honestly I'd put Joe and Wilson above both, and actually Romo is kind of an unknown IMO because he hasn't been to the postseason in 5 years.

This. I also think Rodgers and the Packers are a bit overrated in general - they've been going one and done an awful lot lately.

 

Saying that, if the thread's about ranking QBs that happen to be in the postseason, I can't argue too much with the order.

[Ravenslifer]

This. I also think Rodgers and the Packers are a bit overrated in general - they've been going one and done an awful lot lately.

 

Saying that, if the thread's about ranking QBs that happen to be in the postseason, I can't argue too much with the order.

 

 

As a team maybe, but Rodgers has been decent in his losses - since his Superbowl victory his teams are 1-3, but he personally has completed 64 percent of his passes for 972 yards, 6 TDs and 2 picks in those games.  So he personally has done okay.

[Torreysmithforthewin]

Tbh I think Romo will light it up in the playoffs this year and get that monkey off his back.

[ravensdan]

Just post season best QBs

1. Brady

2. Roethlisberger

3. Flacco

4. Rodgers(outside of the year they won his record is not good)

5. Wilson

6. Manning

7. Luck

8. Romo

9. Newton

10. Dalton

11. Stafford

12. Lindley

[Gordo52]

Just post season best QBs

1. Brady

2. Roethlisberger

3. Flacco

4. Rodgers(outside of the year they won his record is not good)

5. Wilson

6. Manning

7. Luck

8. Romo

9. Newton

10. Dalton

11. Stafford

12. Lindley

This

[ROH522155]

Okay anybody who ranks Joe ahead of Aaron Rodgers is crazy.

 

I think the list should be ranked using 75% how good the QB has been over the course of his career, and 25% how good they've been in past postseasons. Because the postseason is a very small sample size. You guys judging Andrew Luck off of 3 playoff games are just off base.

[beanfigger]

Okay anybody who ranks Joe ahead of Aaron Rodgers is crazy.

I think the list should be ranked using 75% how good the QB has been over the course of his career, and 25% how good they've been in past postseasons. Because the postseason is a very small sample size. You guys judging Andrew Luck off of 3 playoff games are just off base.

I think emphasis needs to be on how they are playing this season, especially the second half of the season. Rodgers is at or near the top in any scenario, though.

[cobrajet]

If Joe outplays Brady next week and then turns around and beats Peyton again (if they end up being there).......Then beats the great Aaron Rodgers (if they end up being there). That would have to shut up all the critics forever........right?

[ROH522155]

1. Aaron Rodgers

2. Tom Brady

3. Peyton Manning

4. Ben Roethlisberger

5. Andrew Luck

6. Joe Flacco

7. Tony Romo

8. Russell Wilson

9. Cam Newton

10. Matthew Stafford

11. Andy Dalton

12. Ryan Lindley

Ranking the remaining QBs

 

1. Aaron Rodgers

2. Tom Brady

3. Peyton Manning

4. January Joe

5. Andrew Luck

6. Tony Romo

7. Russell Wilson

8. Cam Newton

 

The bottom 3 were all taken out. My rankings remain the same except for the fact that I gave Joe a courtesy bump for being so damn good in the playoffs again. If I were to disregard regular season completely, Joe would be number 1 easily.

[Challenge Accepted]

Ranking the remaining QBs

 

1. Aaron Rodgers

2. Tom Brady

3. Peyton Manning

4. January Joe

5. Andrew Luck

6. Tony Romo

7. Russell Wilson

8. Cam Newton

 

The bottom 3 were all taken out. My rankings remain the same except for the fact that I gave Joe a courtesy bump for being so damn good in the playoffs again. If I were to disregard regular season completely, Joe would be number 1 easily.

Peyton manning in January is just despicable imo

[ROH522155]

Peyton manning in January is just despicable imo

 

If an 89.2 passer rating is despicable than yea. 

[ludy51]

1.flacco

-

-

-

5.brady