Hello everyone, it is time for me to share my evaluations for the Forum Mock. I will be going down the order of the depth charts so SAM(the Bengals) is going to be first. I will go through each position group on the team and then state my overall opinion on the team. Once I go through all of the teams that have posted a depth chart, I will rank those teams. Other people are encouraged to share their opinions on the other teams as well and I welcome feedback from the owners/GMs/whatever you want to call yourselves of each team I evaluate. I will do one team a day so that team has the spotlight as well. One other thing to note is that since I am going off the depth charts for each team evaluation, if you haven't posted a depth chart, I can't evaluate your team. So without further ado, let's begin with the Bengals.
Post Your Depth Chart Here
QB: Tony Romo, Josh McCown, Jeff Matthews(UDFA)
RB:Maurice Jones-Drew Giovani Bernard
FB: Greg Jones, Orson Charles
WR: AJ Green, Andrew Hawkins(RFA)
WR: Mario Manningham,Brandon Coleman
WR(slot): Wes Welker
TE: Tyler Eifert, Marcel Jensen , Tyler Brock
LT: Andrew Whitworth Dennis Roland
LG: David Yankey, Dan Koppen
C: Kyle Cook, Trevor Robinson
RG: Kevin Zeitler, Tanner Hawkinson
RT:Donald Penn, Mike Adams,
QB/RB/FB/WR/TE: Trey Burton
LDE: Carlos Dunlap, Margus Hunt, Ben Gardner
DT: Jason Hatcher, Roy Miller Jordan Hill
DT: Geno Atkins, John Jolly
RDE: Trent Cole, Robert Geathers, Morgan Breslin
LOLB: Chad Greenway, James Harrison,
MLB: Vontaze Burfict, Micheal Boley
ROLB: Demeco Ryans, Lamar Woodley
CB: Justin Gilbert, Phillip Adams Aaron Colvin
CB: Derek Cox, Dre Kirkpatrick, Chris Lewis-Harris
CB(slot): Adam Jones, Chris Crocker
FS: Barry Church, Ed Reynolds Joe Lefeged,
SS: George Lloka, Husain Abdullah,Usama Young, Shawn Williams
KR: Marcus Thigpen
PR: Gio Bernard
LS: Clark Harris
Neg this now...
QB: I like Romo, he is well known for choking but I shudder to think how bad the Cowboys would be without him.
RB: I like Gio although only 2 RBs on the roster hurts. MJD has a lot to prove this year, could work out, could crash and burn. I feel like a short yardage type back could really be helpful here.
WR: Solid group here, Green is a stud and a healthy Welker is great as well. Manningham and Hawkins are both fairly good. Coleman has nice potential as the #5 player.
TE: I like Eifert, I like Jensen although he is an unknown, some depth could help here.
O-Line: Solid throughout, weakest link is Yankey but that is because he is an unknown, has potential and I liked him on film.
Front 7: It needs more unnecessary additions....
CB: This is probably the weak point on the team, I like Gilbert and Colvin and Kirkpatrick could get better so the future looks good at this position but I don't know if it will all click this year here. Adam Jones helps in the slot at least.
S: Oh wait you have Barry Church, the secondary is fine lol, Iloka is a decent player as well.
Overall I like the team, CB is a position that is probably the weak spot right now but the future looks promising at least at the position. Other than that, the team is solid and the front 7 is great. The offense looks good as well and Romo should have fun with those guys around him. I haven't evaluated all the other teams but I would imagine this team could at least get in the playoffs or make a strong push.
stm85 and the Philadelphia Eagles are up next.
Edited by 52520Andrew, 18 July 2014 - 10:00 PM.