All Time NFL Team

[Guest Omerta]

You don't know how his full career would have gone is all I'm saying

I understand that but find me a person on this site who does not believe the guy in your avatar will be a top 10 corner next year or top 5 ? With that said also this is nothing more than a Madden exercise with no basis in reality because the concept is so fantastical. 

 

Why would people putt JJ Watt on a list, we have no idea how his career will end, it s only two years in. Why put Calvin on here because his career could end as well and we have no idea how his career will turn out. All anybody is doing with putting a player that isn't retired is guessing how their career goes. The story of Sterling Sharpe is a great cautionary tale because the man would have put up better numbers than Moss, TO, and could very possible be in Jerry Rice's back pocket had he not had a career ending injury. Are we sure any player does not have that around the bend ? We dont so for guys like Jimmy all they are is what they are last year no ?

[BmoreBird22]

I understand that but find me a person on this sight who does not believe the guy in your avatar will be a top 10 corner next year or top 5 ? With that said also this is nothing more than a Madden exercise with no basis in reality because the concept is so fantastical.

Why would people putt JJ Watt on a list, we have no idea how his career will end, it s only two years in. Why put Calvin on here because his career could end as well and we have no idea how his career will turn out. All anybody is doing with putting a player that isn't retired is guessing how their career goes. The story of Sterling Sharpe is a great cautionary tale because the man would have put up better numbers than Moss, TO, and could very possible be in Jerry Rice's back pocket had he not had a career ending injury. Are we sure any player does not have that around the bend ? We dont so for guys like Jimmy all they are is what they are last year no ?

The key word is can. I think Sean Taylor COULD have been an amazing player. He just was not afforded that chance.

I haven't seen JJ Watt on here, but that'd be kinda ridiculous. I think it's a stretch to put Megatron on over guys like Moss or TO, but maybe in due time. If you look at my list, the only not retired player I have om the list is Reed and his career might as well be over

[cobrajet]

QB Joe Montana  (It kills me to not put in Johnny Unitas there, but I think Montana may have had a slight edge)

RB Barry Sanders

TE Tony Gonzalez

WR Jerry Rice

WR Randy Moss

WR Marvin Harrison

T Jonathan Ogden

G Gene Upshaw

C Mike Webster

G John Hannah

T Anthony Munoz

 

DE Reggie White

DT Joe Green
DT Alan Page
DE Deacon Jones
LB Lawrence Taylor
LB Ray Lewis
LB Mike Singletary

CB Deion Sanders
CB Rod Woodson
SS Ronnie Lott
FS Ed Reed
 

 

K Adam Vjnatieri (Believe it or not this one was the hardest to pick, but in the end I had to go clutch over accuracy)

P Ray Guy

PR-KR Brian Mitchell