Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

display name

Top 10 Biggest Free Agent Busts/Trade Acquisitions in Baltimore Ravens History

28 posts in this topic

          While we must give Ozzie in company credit for finding the Ravens good players, no one is without a mistake, and these ten players are among his largest In writing this list I have also heavily taken into account what we gave up for the player: a lot of money, draft picks, etc. Here are the ten biggest free agent/trade acquisition busts in team history:

10) Donte Stallworth, WR, 2010. The Ravens paid him $900,000, had to go out of their way to express support in him, and in return received a mere two catches for 82 yards, and five rushes for 45 yards. He also lost a fumble. We easily could have gotten some undrafted rookie free agent to do that for three times as less and without the drama.

9) Stoney Case, QB, 1999. He started three games and threw 3 touchdowns and 8 interceptions.

7/8) Michael Huff (FS), Marcus Spears (DT), 2013. Can’t really separate them. Both were given a lot of money prior to the 2013 season, part of an array of signings for a defense which had taken an uncharacteristic slip the previous season. Huff embarrassed himself in a 49-27 smacking at the hands of the Broncos in week 1, and his role was mainly reduced to special teams, as rookie safety Matt Elam moved into a starting role. Spears was often injured, and both were released after week 7.

6) Frank Walker, CB, 2008-2009.  :bag: 

5) Dominique Foxworth, CB, 2009-2011. In 2009, he was signed for a 4-year, $28 million contract. He, alongside fellow free agent acquisition Chris Carr and rookie Lardarius Webb, was expected to fill the void left at cornerback that season by the departure of unreliable veterans Chris McAlister and Corey Ivy. Foxworth intercepted four passes in ’09, yet was consistently outrun on deep passes. He tore his ACL in the following minicamp and missed the entire 2010 season. He played two games in 2011 and, after an awful showing in a 26-13 loss in Tennessee, was put on IR, with the story that his knee had still not recovered. He was released. While probably one of the most articulate and intelligent players to players in team history, football-wise, Foxworth was a complete waste of valuable time and money.

4) L.J. Smith, TE, 2009. Smith was signed to a $1.5 million contract, but he recorded only two catches for 32 yards in an injury-plagued season.

3) Scott Mitchell, QB, 1999. One of three QBs in 1999 to start for the Ravens (with Stoney Case and Tony Banks). Banks was the only one to achieve success. Mitchell started two games early in the season, throwing only one touchdown and four interceptions. This was his only season in Baltimore.

2) Elvis Grbac, QB, 2001. He was signed to a 5 year contract, and Brian Billick expected him to give one of the most conservative offenses in NFL history a boost. Yet he started only 14 games in 2001, throwing 15 touchdowns and a disappointing 18 interceptions. He retired following the season.

1) Lee Evans, WR, 2011. Acquired in a trade with the Buffalo Bills, 2011. We paid him a fairly hefty salary and gave up a 4th round pick, thinking he could be the #2 receiver alongside Anquan Boldin. Yet in the first two games of the season he recorded only two catches. Rookie Torrey Smith soon took over the starting role, and Evans finished the season with only 4 catches, and he also dropped a pass or two. He finally seemed to be catching on in the playoffs, but he let a potential touchdown pass in the AFC Championship that would almost certainly have sent Baltimore to the Super Bowl get knocked out of his hands by New England Patriots cornerback Sterling Moore in a loss. He was released in the offseason.

          Thanks for reading.

 

 

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'll never forget Scott Mitchell. While he was getting sacked it reminded me of a water buffalo getting dragged down by a pack of hyenas.

 

Elvis Grbac would have been my #1 since he replaced a SB winng QB. Cunningham was my favorite QB on that team. Grbac stunk!!

 

I personally liked Stoney Case. He had some moxie and I think injuries took him out. Haven't heard that name in a while. Lol.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'll never forget Scott Mitchell. While he was getting sacked it reminded me of a water buffalo getting dragged down by a pack of hyenas.

Elvis Grbac would have been my #1 since he replaced a SB winng QB. Cunningham was my favorite QB on that team. Grbac stunk!!

I personally liked Stoney Case. He had some moxie and I think injuries took him out. Haven't heard that name in a while. Lol.

Personally I wouldn't have put Grbac so high. Sure he gets a lot of grief, but Jamal went down and was out for the year. Grbac at least kept us competitive and got us into the playoffs. IMO, no way Dilfer does anything with that team if we kept him.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Frank Walker was by far the worst player we have ever had. I remember a play where he got called for holding AND PI on the same play!! And STILL gave up a 40 yard TD!!!! I have never seen a single player get flagged twice on the same play!!!! Horrible.
5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If those are our biggest busts, we're doing okay

 

Agreed. Most of those were minor signings (Case, for instance was brought in to be the 3rd QB).

 

IMO, Grbac has to be the top dog because of the cost and what he was supposed to be - and wasn't.

 

I'd also add Leon Searcy and Frank Sanders to the list based on the contracts they received and the role they were expected to play.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Definitely Spears/Huff when you consider the money we gave to them that could have gone to keeping around a certain WR still playing in the playoffs ... 

-7

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
My number 1 is ,,ELVIS GRBAC, he came in to help our offense instead he helped himself to a fat paycheck and then ladies and gentlemen "Elvis left the building"( could not resist)
4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

From  what my old man and his buddies tell me, it's Grbac. He could have been the difference that would have made that team a dynasty. 

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Erik Williams, only because he was such an animal and not THAT old.  Grbac and Foxworth I knew weren't that great, much like the rest.

 

You knew something was up with Lee Evans other than just the emergence of Steve Johnson in Buffalo.  He was their guy for a while, then they're suddenly willing to part with him?  It's rarely that easy. 

 

Huff and Spears were both basically first round busts and we didn't give them big contracts.  I think we were just testing whether they were good after all and just hindered in Oakland and Dallas.  Nah, just not great players.

 

Frank Walker should've  never had any expectations or much playing time.  Scott Mitchell was well known to be the beneficiary of Herman Moore, Jonnie Morton, and Barry Sanders in Detroit and not anything special himself.  LJ Smith had some success in routes down the seam in Philly but, again, if they're suddenly willing to part with him there's likely a reason, and there was.  Injuries/bad hands.  Donte Stallworth, I think, had some ability for big plays but we only tried it once all year, did 4 end arounds, and that was it.  He was coming back to football so you temper your expectations.

 

Grbac had big passing numbers in KC; it seemed like if you added that to our 2000 defense, we'd win about 5 straight Super Bowls.  Running with Jason Brookings, Moe Williams, and Terry Allen was ok but certainly not Jamal Lewis, the defense wasn't as dominant, and nobody's putting up big numbers with the likes of Travis Taylor, Patrick Johnson, and an injured Stokley.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In my mind Elvis has always been the biggest bust. It was painful to watch. But I have to agree with the op. Evans came with so much promise, hardly played and was responsible for the worst play in Ravens history. Makes me cringe to think about it. argggghhhh!!!

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It tells how good are front office is. Not catastrophically huge FA busts. If lee evans was truly are biggest FA mistake, the ravens are magic.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If those are our biggest busts, we're doing okay

 

This.  If these are the worst acquisitions we've had, we're doing pretty well.  Most were low dollar, 1 year pacts that just didn't work out.  Only a few were truly bad contracts that hurt for a couple of years.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Foxworth should be #1 imo. Sure Lee Evans cost us the AFC championship game, but Foxworth cost us a lot of money and did jack.

 

And then Evans would be #2, Grbac would be #3 for me, and then Mitchell.

 

Still extremely disappointed in Huff. Thought he could at least somewhat replace Reed. I was very wrong. lol. And i'm not really sure why LJ Smith is so high. He only signed the small 1 year, 1.5 million, and wasn't expected to start. I didn't really expect him to produce tbh.

1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Anyone remember Keydrick Vincent??? I would take down guys like Frank Walker and LJ Smith because these were basically guys who needed to compete for a roster spot not guys who were expected to start for multiple years

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Someone didn't read the title...

Oh okay.  Then the topic is weak because (free agents/traded players) really come in to fill voids.

 

 Hard to expect anything that you haven't seen in the players, prior to bringing them in. 

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

          While we must give Ozzie in company credit for finding the Ravens good players, no one is without a mistake, and these ten players are among his largest In writing this list I have also heavily taken into account what we gave up for the player: a lot of money, draft picks, etc. Here are the ten biggest free agent/trade acquisition busts in team history:

10) Donte Stallworth, WR, 2010. The Ravens paid him $900,000, had to go out of their way to express support in him, and in return received a mere two catches for 82 yards, and five rushes for 45 yards. He also lost a fumble. We easily could have gotten some undrafted rookie free agent to do that for three times as less and without the drama.

9) Stoney Case, QB, 1999. He started three games and threw 3 touchdowns and 8 interceptions.

7/8) Michael Huff (FS), Marcus Spears (DT), 2013. Can’t really separate them. Both were given a lot of money prior to the 2013 season, part of an array of signings for a defense which had taken an uncharacteristic slip the previous season. Huff embarrassed himself in a 49-27 smacking at the hands of the Broncos in week 1, and his role was mainly reduced to special teams, as rookie safety Matt Elam moved into a starting role. Spears was often injured, and both were released after week 7.

6) Frank Walker, CB, 2008-2009.  :bag: 

5) Dominique Foxworth, CB, 2009-2011. In 2009, he was signed for a 4-year, $28 million contract. He, alongside fellow free agent acquisition Chris Carr and rookie Lardarius Webb, was expected to fill the void left at cornerback that season by the departure of unreliable veterans Chris McAlister and Corey Ivy. Foxworth intercepted four passes in ’09, yet was consistently outrun on deep passes. He tore his ACL in the following minicamp and missed the entire 2010 season. He played two games in 2011 and, after an awful showing in a 26-13 loss in Tennessee, was put on IR, with the story that his knee had still not recovered. He was released. While probably one of the most articulate and intelligent players to players in team history, football-wise, Foxworth was a complete waste of valuable time and money.

4) L.J. Smith, TE, 2009. Smith was signed to a $1.5 million contract, but he recorded only two catches for 32 yards in an injury-plagued season.

3) Scott Mitchell, QB, 1999. One of three QBs in 1999 to start for the Ravens (with Stoney Case and Tony Banks). Banks was the only one to achieve success. Mitchell started two games early in the season, throwing only one touchdown and four interceptions. This was his only season in Baltimore.

2) Elvis Grbac, QB, 2001. He was signed to a 5 year contract, and Brian Billick expected him to give one of the most conservative offenses in NFL history a boost. Yet he started only 14 games in 2001, throwing 15 touchdowns and a disappointing 18 interceptions. He retired following the season.

1) Lee Evans, WR, 2011. Acquired in a trade with the Buffalo Bills, 2011. We paid him a fairly hefty salary and gave up a 4th round pick, thinking he could be the #2 receiver alongside Anquan Boldin. Yet in the first two games of the season he recorded only two catches. Rookie Torrey Smith soon took over the starting role, and Evans finished the season with only 4 catches, and he also dropped a pass or two. He finally seemed to be catching on in the playoffs, but he let a potential touchdown pass in the AFC Championship that would almost certainly have sent Baltimore to the Super Bowl get knocked out of his hands by New England Patriots cornerback Sterling Moore in a loss. He was released in the offseason.

          Thanks for reading.

 

 

I never felt that Stallworth was utilized properly by Cam.  He just came in for endarounds.  Smh!  Kind of like what we're seeing now with our players.  Torrey just seems to run 9 routes.  Very rarely does he run slants, drags, curls, ins and out routes etc.

 

#Mili

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Frank Walker was by far the worst player we have ever had. I remember a play where he got called for holding AND PI on the same play!! And STILL gave up a 40 yard TD!!!! I have never seen a single player get flagged twice on the same play!!!! Horrible.

the horror that I feel in my heart when I hear that name...
1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

foxworth is worst by far.

 

big name signing who was terrible.

 

stallworth wasent used right TBH.

we rather had boldin and mason go deep except him.

i think he went deep 1 time was thrown at, caught it , everyone eyes got big, last time it was seen lol.

 

intresting no fabian washington lol.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If those are our biggest busts, we're doing okay


I know, right? This list is a joke.
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

And yet he lasted two years.

He lasted two years because in his first year, 2008, he actually exceeded expectations and played pretty well. No one remembers it, though, because 2009 was such a train wreck.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites