Trade proposed to me:

[bauer77]

This is a 12 team, deep bench, 2 QB league. So we start 2 QBs, 2 RBs, 3 WRs, 1 TE, the normal WR/RB flex, and then a WR/TE/RB flex. My team is as follows.

 

QB: Matt Schaub and Jay Cutler

RB: Trent Richardson, Bilal Powell, Rashard Mendenhall, Rashad Jennings

WR: Marques Colston, Danny Amendola, Brandon Marshall, Roddy White, Chris Givens, Michael Floyd, Steve Smith, Brandon LaFell. 

TE: Jermichael Finley, Heath Miller.

 

Just so you know, my team was auto drafted, that's why i have so many WRs, no backup QB, and only 3 RBs. lol. Kicker and defense don't really matter. I play the matchups most of the time with them anyway. 

 

But now to the question. I was offered this trade:

James Jones and Eddie Lacy      for 

Roddy White and Danny Amendola.

 

I was going to accept it, simply because I'm very thin at RB, and Amendola is injury prone anyway. I just didn't want to look foolish if Roddy White gets healthy and starts to have a pro-bowl type year again.

[PuRock]

This trade could go either way.  You have enough fire  power at WR to offset the trade and you can always afford to get another starting RB.

 

But then again you are given him Amendola and Roddy White, after you suffered through the wait.  Anyway to counter and sweeten the deal with something a tab better than James Jones?  Eddie Lacy hasn't exactly proven himself to be the picture of health yet either.  

 

Overall, I think I would take this deal just because of your RB situation.  After getting Eddie Lacy, I would try to shore up his backup (once he comes back the Starks/Franklin owners will probably drop tthem).

[bauer77]

This trade could go either way.  You have enough fire  power at WR to offset the trade and you can always afford to get another starting RB.

 

But then again you are given him Amendola and Roddy White, after you suffered through the wait.  Anyway to counter and sweeten the deal with something a tab better than James Jones?  Eddie Lacy hasn't exactly proven himself to be the picture of health yet either.  

 

Overall, I think I would take this deal just because of your RB situation.  After getting Eddie Lacy, I would try to shore up his backup (once he comes back the Starks/Franklin owners will probably drop tthem).

 

Alright, he ended up cancelling this trade, but i just got offered another. 

White and Amendola   for

Randall Cobb and DeMarco Murray

 

Thoughts?

[PuRock]

Alright, he ended up cancelling this trade, but i just got offered another. 

White and Amendola   for

Randall Cobb and DeMarco Murray

 

Thoughts?

 

Done.  I prefer this offer over the last one. I would do this move since you are low on RB.  This is a much sweeter deal.

 

He must have gotten cold feet on Lacy when he heard the positive news on him this week.

[Alexir]

Alright, he ended up cancelling this trade, but i just got offered another. 

White and Amendola   for

Randall Cobb and DeMarco Murray

 

Thoughts?

 

I hope you are getting Cobb and Murray or else this is terrible.

[PuRock]

I hope you are getting Cobb and Murray or else this is terrible.

 

He is.  And he's giving up Amendola and White when he already has Colston and Brandon Marshall.  

[codizzle]

Alright, he ended up cancelling this trade, but i just got offered another.
White and Amendola for
Randall Cobb and DeMarco Murray

Thoughts?

Automatic yes considering your roster

[mg90]

Automatic yes considering your roster

That's an automatic yes no matter what....with potential for a veto I'd say. If injuries could just completely vanish from White and Amendola it might be fair.

[reediddy]

Alright, he ended up cancelling this trade, but i just got offered another. 

White and Amendola   for

Randall Cobb and DeMarco Murray

 

Thoughts?

 

I'd do this in a heartbeat