Fantasy Injury Thread

[Sizzlebshu]

Figured it'd be worth having. Anyway Jamaal Charles was carted off the field with a foot strain. X-Rays negative with a possible MRI coming. 

 

 

[berad]

Doesn't this kinda coincide with the normal injury thread

[Gordo52]

Doesn't this kinda coincide with the normal injury thread

Could also be a injury vent thread for fantasy purposes.

[flaccopoe]

Doesn't this kinda coincide with the normal injury thread

 

Lock it up!  :lock: 

[mg90]

[quote name="berad" post="1537730" timestamp="1376325138"]

Doesn't this kinda coincide with the normal injury thread[/quote

There is definitely a difference in which players would be talked about. Could also bring up conversation about who to grab because of an injury.

[mg90]

Doesn't this kinda coincide with the normal injury thread

There is definitely a difference in which players would be talked about. Could also bring up conversation about who to grab because of an injury.

[berad]

There is definitely a difference in which players would be talked about. Could also bring up conversation about who to grab because of an injury.

This is the best argument I've seen for it (with the replacements) but I still think there's a lot of overlap.

[CARavensFan]

This is the best argument I've seen for it (with the replacements) but I still think there's a lot of overlap.

 

The main reason I could think for having this in additional to the other injury thread is this is where you could discuss the implications of an injury on fantasy players (guys to step up behind the player, potential sleepers to replace an indued guy, etc.) while the other injury thread is more about the impact the injury has on a real NFL team and their season. An injury that has a big impact in fantasy doesn't always have as big an impact in real NFL games and vice versa.

 

edit: It could be a place to discuss game-time decision guys or other "probable, questionable, etc" players as not everyone who comes on here enjoys fantasy football so having that discussion be in the regular injury thread could lead to some annoyance by other people.

[flaccopoe]

The main reason I could think for having this in additional to the other injury thread is this is where you could discuss the implications of an injury on fantasy players (guys to step up behind the player, potential sleepers to replace an indued guy, etc.) while the other injury thread is more about the impact the injury has on a real NFL team and their season. An injury that has a big impact in fantasy doesn't always have as big an impact in real NFL games and vice versa.

 

edit: It could be a place to discuss game-time decision guys or other "probable, questionable, etc" players as not everyone who comes on here enjoys fantasy football so having that discussion be in the regular injury thread could lead to some annoyance by other people.

 

I could just make a "2013-2014 Fantasy Discussion Thread".

[berad]

The main reason I could think for having this in additional to the other injury thread is this is where you could discuss the implications of an injury on fantasy players (guys to step up behind the player, potential sleepers to replace an indued guy, etc.) while the other injury thread is more about the impact the injury has on a real NFL team and their season. An injury that has a big impact in fantasy doesn't always have as big an impact in real NFL games and vice versa.

edit: It could be a place to discuss game-time decision guys or other "probable, questionable, etc" players as not everyone who comes on here enjoys fantasy football so having that discussion be in the regular injury thread could lead to some annoyance by other people.

Sounds good to me, I'll delete my earlier post

[flaccopoe]

Sounds good to me, I'll delete my earlier post

 

I made a "Fantasy Discussion Thread to comply with your assessment regarding overlap.

[berad]

I made a "Fantasy Discussion Thread to comply with your assessment regarding overlap.

 

Haha now that's TOO broad.

[flaccopoe]

Haha now that's TOO broad.

 

What?  Someone makes a Fantasy Discussion Thread every season.  That way, we can discuss everything pertinent in 1 Thread, instead of everyone's personal Threads, like we've been doing this offseason.

[Moderator 3]

That's like trying to combine all of Ravens Talk into one thread.

[flaccopoe]

That's like trying to combine all of Ravens Talk into one thread.

 

Maybe you should rename it the "Start or Sit Thread" since we're keeping the Fantasy Injury Thread.