Luck Or Flacco?!

[Latch]

[quote name='ratedr' timestamp='1357461673' post='1291464']
Flacco tomorrow, Luck in the future.

[b] Though I'm taking Wilson and RGIII over Luck anyday. [/b]
[/quote]

So, therefore, Wilson and RG3 over Flacco?

[PolishRifle]

I am not taking anyone based on promises and other peoples opinions (analyst hyperbole). Flacco brought the team to 5 playoffs in 5 seasons, reached 2 AFCCG and if one of his receivers would've held onto a very catchable ball, he would've made it to the SB, maybe even won it.
You can try to discredit him, by stating how great our defense was, but it certainly was not great this season and there are plenty of teams with a great defense, that sat out the playoffs plenty of times coughBearscough.
I'll take Flacco until Luck, RG3, Cam or whoever proves himself with actual results, that he is actually better. Rodgers winning MVP honors and a SB. Sure looks like the better QB right now, but Wilson who just started and has done nothing of note. No thank you.

BTW, we might be the only team, that has a QB with a historically great record and we still would choose someone over him, even the backup QB who fell deep in the draft.
Joe did only win a ton of games or put our team atleast in a winning position in a division filled with the best defenses in the league, having to start from the get go, working with an offense, that is treated like red headed stepchild during the draft, while playing under Cam Cameron and facing ridiculous pressure and scrutiny from literally EVERYONE. I am sorry, Andrew Who?

[Raven Hammer]

[quote name='ratedr' timestamp='1357461673' post='1291464']
Flacco tomorrow, Luck in the future.

Though I'm taking Wilson and RGIII over Luck anyday.
[/quote]
I can't figure you guys Your talking about three unproven QB's What we have here has a track record and a good one at that I am not going to trade that for three in a bush. In a year or two Maybe!!!

[Hardbaugh]

Just this Sunday I'd take Flacco. I'm a believer that Luck will still have a better game at the Bank then if Flacco were in Indy though.

If you were to ask what quarterback I'd feel better with next week in Denver not to mention going forward I'd say Luck all day .

Flacco has proven to this point to be an average quarterback. I won't predict his future other than to say he needs to get on the horse. Luck looks like he is a star in the making and should be great if he has the ability to stay healthy. Staying on the field and toughness are two traits of Flacco's that aren't in question.

People always call me a Flacco hater but I'm just speaking on what I see. I root hard for this guy because as Flacco goes so do the Ravens. I root for the colors above any player................[u]ALWAYS[/u]

[ewl21]

Flacco for his experience, however Luck has come a long way in his rookie season. Flacco needs to work on 2 things: (1)His short passing game and (2)His ability to move around in the pocket. I believe if Flacco improved in these 2 areas, he would elevate himself from just an average QB to an elite QB!! Time will tell.

[ravensdfan]

[quote name='Hardbaugh' timestamp='1357488279' post='1291593']
Just this Sunday I'd take Flacco. I'm a believer that Luck will still have a better game at the Bank then if Flacco were in Indy though.

If you were to ask what quarterback I'd feel better with next week in Denver not to mention going forward I'd say Luck all day .

Flacco has proven to this point to be an average quarterback. I won't predict his future other than to say he needs to get on the horse. [b]Luck looks like he is a star in the making and should be great if he has the ability to stay healthy.[/b] Staying on the field and toughness are two traits of Flacco's that aren't in question.

People always call me a Flacco hater but I'm just speaking on what I see. I root hard for this guy because as Flacco goes so do the Ravens. I root for the colors above any player................[u]ALWAYS[/u]
[/quote]

Based on what? Yardage? Because even if you compare rookie seasons, it is the only area he surpasses Flacco. So far this particular season (not saying it will be an ongoing trend) Luck has proven to be a turnover machine. He not only has more INTs than Flacco but more fumbles as well.

Honestly, I think people on these boards have overdosed on ESPN and the so-called experts. They are now just regurgitating the nonsense.

Luck may well become great. Currently, he has not proven to be such a thing though. It is absurd to annoint these rookies until they've done anything consistent. We've all seen this before, and the crowns come falling down.

[CapoRocky]

I think the battle will be won by the defense. We must find a way to stop Luck and his receivers. Flacco should win this game based on experience in the playoffs. Let's just out to a big lead and hold it in the 4th quarter. If Flacco wins, then I see a big contract. If not, then he will be franchised and the contract will be reset for another year.

[theblackdog]

[quote name='Mr. Irrelevant' timestamp='1357338154' post='1289628']
Exactly............ Pags cannot be that stupid though
[/quote]

Nah, Pags isn't that stupid, but Jim Irsay and Ryan Grigson are.

[flynismo]

Is this still masquerading as a serious question?

[SecretAgentMan]

[quote name='flynismo' timestamp='1358055619' post='1308654']
Is this still masquerading as a serious question?
[/quote]
Luck is elite here in the bay area....

So as long as I exist sadly yes

IF Flacco wins a SB he is going to go down as one of the greatest young QB's ever. Greatest ever in his first five years in the most important statistic. WINS.

Luck has a ways to go if Joe wins it all

[BloodRaven]

[quote name='ratedr' timestamp='1357461673' post='1291464']
Flacco tomorrow, Luck in the future.

Though I'm taking Wilson and RGIII over Luck anyday.
[/quote]

For draft value I'd take Wilson over either, if I had to pick one for equal value it would be Luck.