13 replies to this topic

[Juviebest]

Wanted opinions:

Austin Collie is available and would love to have him.

Who should I drop for him? Daniel Thomas or Mike Williams?

My RB's:
MJD
Doug Martin
DeMarco Murray
Sproles
Dwyer
Thomas

My WR's:
Fitz
Torrey
Q
Titus Young
Mike Williams

[Alexir]

Wanted opinions:

Austin Collie is available and would love to have him.

Who should I drop for him? Daniel Thomas or Mike Williams?

My RB's:
MJD
Doug Martin
DeMarco Murray
Sproles
Dwyer
Thomas

My WR's:
Fitz
Torrey
Q
Titus Young
Mike Williams

Honestly, I would pass on him. Your running backs are already shaky, I wouldn't add an injury prone receiver especially with the team the WR Corps you have now. Also, IMO, your weakest link at WR is Q. I see young and williams having a great year.

[usmccharles]

Drop Q keep williams, way more upside. Collie has injury issues, hes peolly a better option than Q but i dont see a scenario where you would start him over who you have

[Juviebest]

Honestly, I would pass on him. Your running backs are already shaky, I wouldn't add an injury prone receiver especially with the team the WR Corps you have now. Also, IMO, your weakest link at WR is Q. I see young and williams having a great year.

I actually love my RB's, haha. PPR league so that bumps them up dramatically, especially Sproles.

I just think Collie and Luck click. It's obvious that Collie will be the #1 target...no offense to Wayne. Plus more targets = more catches...PPR. Like you stated he's injury prone and that's the only thing that worries me.

[gabefergy]

Id drop williams for collie in a ppr. Could backfire if collie gets another concussion but he looked like Lucks go to guy.

[Alexir]

Drop Q keep williams, way more upside. Collie has injury issues, hes peolly a better option than Q but i dont see a scenario where you would start him over who you have

Yeah, I would drop Q for Collie.

Williams should return to form this year.

[Corvus Amplus]

Don't drop Q!!!

I believe Q is going to breakout in our offense because Cam is finally putting him in the slot. Q is going to put up some good numbers in the slot. I expect a WR2 production out of Q this year. Q has been getting a lot fo redzone looks and the Ravens are planning to throw more in the redzone to keep Rice fresh.

[Mt. Crushmore]

I would drop Daniel Thomas.

[Free Agent]

I would drop Jonathan Dwyer, when Mendenhall gets back he's going to be the 3rd, or maybe the 4th Steelers RB. No need to keep him around.

[Ravens<3]

Honestly, I would pass on him. Your running backs are already shaky, I wouldn't add an injury prone receiver especially with the team the WR Corps you have now. Also, IMO, your weakest link at WR is Q. I see young and williams having a great year.

I think his RBs look as solid as they come!

I would drop Dwyer for him.

[BMOREHAWAII]

Wanted opinions:

Austin Collie is available and would love to have him.

Who should I drop for him? Daniel Thomas or Mike Williams?

My RB's:
MJD
Doug Martin
DeMarco Murray
Sproles
Dwyer
Thomas

My WR's:
Fitz
Torrey
Q
Titus Young
Mike Williams

I would drop MJD and Demarco Murray and pickup Collie and leave the extra bench just in case. Seems smart..

Nice team BTW

[Juviebest]

I think his RBs look as solid as they come!

I would drop Dwyer for him.

Thanks, I think Dwyer could have a big week one. Redman is hurt and no way Mendenhall plays. Then I'd like to flip him for a decent RB2. Plus I hate having a Steeler on my team.

[Medications]

Collie's head is made of Jello, i honestly wouldn't bother picking him up, he'll most likely only play in a small handful of games this season. He's wayyy too concussion prone.

It's too early to drop any of your receivers, Mike Williams could wind up having a good year with VJax on the other side. And Q is a decent backup to Torrey, because we all know Torrey is going to wind up missing a game or two this year with that ankle. And Young will probably have some sort of breakout year as well so I wouldn't drop any of your receivers at this stage.

Edited by Medications, 08 September 2012 - 02:11 PM.

[Juviebest]

So I ended up dropping Daniel Thomas for Randall Cobb and Mike Williams for Ogletree. Decided to hold off on Collie.