Who Would You Rather Draft?

[usmccharles]

[quote name='gabefergy' timestamp='1344638336' post='1116846']
He already had two RBs though and ended up not taking a WR til 6th round. I dont tlike that strategy at all, but hey to each his own.
[/quote]

i actually plan on doing the exact same thing possibly. With the rb group so thin, i think its better to try to get 3 top rbs, obviously depending whose there. i have the 8th pick in my 10team league, with rice and foster as my keepers, i really want hillis as my flex and i think i can get him in the 5th, but if steven jackson/fjax/mcgahee maybe is there ill be tempted to take one of them. there is so many wr's this year and i dont even have a 4th round, im not even sure where ill grab my qb yet,,,,i think there is plenty of value late

[gabefergy]

[quote name='usmccharles' timestamp='1344641449' post='1116860']
i actually plan on doing the exact same thing possibly. With the rb group so thin, i think its better to try to get 3 top rbs, obviously depending whose there. i have the 8th pick in my 10team league, with rice and foster as my keepers, i really want hillis as my flex and i think i can get him in the 5th, but if steven jackson/fjax/mcgahee maybe is there ill be tempted to take one of them. there is so many wr's this year and i dont even have a 4th round, im not even sure where ill grab my qb yet,,,,i think there is plenty of value late
[/quote]
Personally. I'd rather get an elite WR, QB, or TE if I already have two stud RBs but I can understand that approach. My take is just that after the top 3 RBs all the other ones come with questions.

I'm in a similar situation in a keeper league, I have Foster and McCoy as my keepers with the #1 pick. I'm planning on taking Rodgers, Brees, Brady, Graham, or Megatron depending on who is available though.

[Ed_Reed20]

[quote name='gabefergy' timestamp='1344638336' post='1116846']
He already had two RBs though and ended up not taking a WR til 6th round. I dont tlike that strategy at all, but hey to each his own.
[/quote]

Agreed. The WR position is deep but there's no way I'm putting off drafting one till that late.

On to another debate. There are several WRs with similar ADPs but I chose two I'm high on:

Antonio Brown or Jeremy Maclin

[gabefergy]

[quote name='Ed_Reed20' timestamp='1344643140' post='1116873']
Agreed. The WR position is deep but there's no way I'm putting off drafting one till that late.

On to another debate. There are several WRs with similar ADPs but I chose two I'm high on:

Antonio Brown or Jeremy Maclin
[/quote]
I have Brown slightly ahead of Maclin on my board, but I like both. Brown has been steadily climbing up my ranks.

[usmccharles]

[quote name='gabefergy' timestamp='1344642171' post='1116864']

Personally. I'd rather get an elite WR, QB, or TE if I already have two stud RBs but I can understand that approach. My take is just that after the top 3 RBs all the other ones come with questions.

I'm in a similar situation in a keeper league, I have Foster and McCoy as my keepers with the #1 pick. I'm planning on taking Rodgers, Brees, Brady, Graham, or Megatron depending on who is available though.
[/quote]

Well i agree, but im pretty confident that the elite qbs wrs will be gone by the 28th pick. For TE im gonna go after hernandez late. I guess my 3rd is still undecided, just depends whose there.

Ill take brown ovwr maclin

[Gordo52]

Eli or Peyton?

I'm going Eli. I think he's a second tier QB this year. Right next to Newton,Cutler and Romo.

[Mt. Crushmore]

[quote name='Ravens<3' timestamp='1345056528' post='1119706']
Eli or Peyton?

I'm going Eli. I think he's a second tier QB this year. Right next to Newton,Cutler and Romo.
[/quote]

Eli

[Gordo52]

Cutler or Eli? Qb leauge.

[BMOREHAWAII]

Seeing as you all love Flacco so much, how about you pick him the first chance you get .... LMAO.

[usmccharles]

[quote name='Ravens<3' timestamp='1345165133' post='1120808']
Cutler or Eli? Qb leauge.
[/quote]

cutler. although the oline scares me but with him having marshall and forte and the rookie they drafted, i think he has a good year

[Gordo52]

Fred Jackson or Ryan Mathews?

[Mt. Crushmore]

[quote name='Ravens<3' timestamp='1345331447' post='1123450']
Fred Jackson or Ryan Mathews?
[/quote]

Jackson.

[BMOREHAWAII]

[quote name='Ravens<3' timestamp='1345331447' post='1123450']
Fred Jackson or Ryan Mathews?
[/quote]
Good one. Age and durability vs. youth and injury probability.
I would take Matthews because i dont mind a gamble. Also he is prone to have a breakout year when he returns (that's if he doesn't get hurt). I like how his RB style would fit SD well, Tomlinson like.

[Gordo52]

[quote name='BMOREHAWAII' timestamp='1345338292' post='1123517']
Good one. Age and durability vs. youth and injury probability.
I would take Matthews because i dont mind a gamble. Also he is prone to have a breakout year when he returns (that's if he doesn't get hurt). I like how his RB style would fit SD well, Tomlinson like.
[/quote]
I agree, both carry alot of risk though in my eyes. Both are as solid as it gets for #2 RBs.

[usmccharles]

[quote name='Ravens<3' timestamp='1345331447' post='1123450']
Fred Jackson or Ryan Mathews?
[/quote]

Jackson. I will not touch mathews unless he slips very far, the dude has been listed on the injury report for 50% of his games, hes even missed games when probable, i just think he is way too risky because of the health issues. I know jackson was hurt last year, but even with missing 6 games he was still a top ten fantasy rb, i dont expect the same production but i think he has a top ten year.

[gabefergy]

[quote name='Ravens<3' timestamp='1345331447' post='1123450']
Fred Jackson or Ryan Mathews?
[/quote]
Jackson. I dont trust Mathews at all.