Which Qb Would You All Choose

[T-ray]

Okay, I have a question, more of out of curiousity than anything, but I need to know who you'd draft if you were going with any QB under these rules.

Pass TD: 4 pts
Pass Yds: 25 yds per 1 pt; 2 pts at 20 yds; 3 pts at 30; 5 pts at 50
INT: -1 pt
Run TD: 6 pts
Run Yds: 10 yds per 1 pt; 2 pt at 20; 3 pts at 30; 5 pts at 50
Fumbles Lost: -2 pts

Under standard scoring, and without looking at these rules, I would take Rodgers or Brady all day long, every day of the week. However, Vick looks awfully tempting with the rush yds/tds the way they're set up.

[Gordo52]

Vick/Rodgers/Brady/Rivers/Brees

[BMOREHAWAII]

1.Rodgers - Great deep ball and effictively runs the ball well when need be.

2.Vick - Obviously, the better running Qb out of the group and has speedy receiver's to get the YAC.

3.Brady/Rivers - Brady being so accurate, and Rivers who probably has the best deep ball in the league.

4.Brees - Great Qb, not to fond of his receiving core.

Basically took Rodgers over Vick because he IMO the best all-around Qb in the league, who also has one of the better if not the best O-lines in the league. Also Vick sketchy because him being a Qb with that type of speed and who is willing to take off, is bound to get hurt (just saying). Also you can expect NOTHING BUT points from Brady and Rivers. My OWN two cents...