Madden Rating For The Rookies

[63bru]

These are just my guesses, I don't really know. I wanted to know what everyone else thought.

Jimmy Smith- 78 ovr, 92 speed
Torrey Smith- 74 ovr, 94 speed
Jah Reid- 70 ovr, 90 strength
Tandon Doss- 71 ovr, 86 speed
Chykie Brown- 66 ovr, 87 speed
Pernell McPhee- 68 ovr, 69 speed, 78 strength
Tyrod Taylor- 52 ovr, 84 speed
Anthony Allen- 67 ovr, 84 speed

For what it's worth, I think the top rated rookies will be Patrick Peterson (85), Marcell Dareus (if they list him at DT, 84), AJ Green (84), and Von Miller (83). Lowest rated first round pick will probably be Christian Ponder. I'd guess in the low 70s for him.

[theFRANCHISE]

Those ratings, more or less, seem about right. I think Jimmy Smith and Torrey Smith will definitely be our highest-rated rookies on the team, and Torrey will probably be rated higher than some other 2nd-round players taken since he had a 1st-round grade, similar to how Sergio Kindle was given a generous rating.

[jimmysmith3]

right on duuuuuuuuuuuude

[Bltravens]

I had my posted somewhere, but I cant see McPhee being rated higher than anyone else we took in this class. He's a junior college transfer that didnt put up great numbers, that almost never translates to Madden. I see Taylor being rated in the mid to high 60s, he's an accomplished player has all the tools for Madden, and the only way to downgrade a rookie QB is awareness ratings so that will be low.

Franny you sure you don't mean JSmith is like Kindle last year and not Torrey? Kindle and Smith were top 15 picks as on field guys. Torrey was being graded out towards the end as a 2nd round guy.

[20ravens52]

[quote name='Bltravens' timestamp='1305997567' post='689244']
I had my posted somewhere
[/quote]

It's about 5 topics behind this one. It's titled Madden 12 Rookie Ratings...

This topic is kinda the same thing, guess the moderators didn't catch that

[Free Agent]

[quote name='63bru' timestamp='1305858987' post='688753']
These are just my guesses, I don't really know. I wanted to know what everyone else thought.

Jimmy Smith- 78 ovr, 92 speed
Torrey Smith- 74 ovr, 94 speed
Jah Reid- 70 ovr, 90 strength
Tandon Doss- 71 ovr, 86 speed
Chykie Brown- 66 ovr, 87 speed
Pernell McPhee- 68 ovr, 69 speed, 78 strength
Tyrod Taylor- 52 ovr, 84 speed
Anthony Allen- 67 ovr, 84 speed

For what it's worth, I think the top rated rookies will be Patrick Peterson (85), Marcell Dareus (if they list him at DT, 84), AJ Green (84), and Von Miller (83). Lowest rated first round pick will probably be Christian Ponder. I'd guess in the low 70s for him.
[/quote]

Good ratings, although I would have Tyrod Taylor in mid to high 60s. I think 52 is too low. I will be interested to see what his rating will be if converted to RB.