Madden 12 Rookie Ratings

[-Truth-]

Casey Mathews is rated higher than Brooks Reed and Martez Wilson. I'm done. On a side note, Patrick Peterson, welcome to every Madden '12 Online Franchise I'll ever be in.

[wayne]

They rate them like that based on where they got drafted and Prince went before Smith and you got what you got.

[Bltravens]

[quote name='wayne' timestamp='1311535228' post='712278']
They rate them like that based on where they got drafted and Prince went before Smith and you got what you got.
[/quote]
Not entirely true, they have Brooks Reed rated lower than Casey Matthews. I dont know how theyre going to justify Amukamura higher than JSmith. If life was like Madden with no "off field issues" JSmith would have gone to Houston at #11.

[SuRihtanil]

I hate it when the majority of the players on madden are in the 90s. I think J. Smith will be our highest rated rookie, he should probably be around 77? T. Smith will probably be around 74 the rest of our guys should be low 70s high 60s. I am of course guessing on our ratings, but like I said I hated it on madden 09/2010 when everyone ended up with ratings above 85, 08 was the worse, you had FA sitting in the pool in the 80s because every team was stacked because the rookies were in the 80s starting out.

Madden 2011 did alright to combat the high rating issue, but its still a lingering thing, I think 2012 looks even more promising with the traits, and week by week, hot and cold spells from players. I also think I read something about rookies will now have ?? as ratings? You actually have to play with them and work with them to learn if they're worth keeping or not.

[3-4 Assault]

Still over a month away from this game :mad:

Can't wait to get this.

[AwakenTheDemon]

[quote name='SuRihtanil' timestamp='1311742881' post='717014']
I hate it when the majority of the players on madden are in the 90s. I think J. Smith will be our highest rated rookie, he should probably be around 77? T. Smith will probably be around 74 the rest of our guys should be low 70s high 60s. I am of course guessing on our ratings, but like I said I hated it on madden 09/2010 when everyone ended up with ratings above 85, 08 was the worse, you had FA sitting in the pool in the 80s because every team was stacked because the rookies were in the 80s starting out.

Madden 2011 did alright to combat the high rating issue, but its still a lingering thing, I think 2012 looks even more promising with the traits, and week by week, hot and cold spells from players. [b]I also think I read something about rookies will now have ?? as ratings? You actually have to play with them and work with them to learn if they're worth keeping or not.[/b]
[/quote]

That's partially true. It's part of the new scouting system, but there won't be any "??" ratings in the actual season itself, only preseason.

[jimmysmith3]

[quote name='JO_75' timestamp='1311336943' post='711224']
Didn't see this posted but figured to post it here. OS has a list of Top 10 Rookie Overalls based on Position.

Top 10 Rookie DB: http://www.operationsports.com/forums/madden-nfl-football/496003-madden-nfl-12-rookie-ratings-top-ten-defensive-backs.html

Top 10 Rookie LB: http://www.operationsports.com/forums/madden-nfl-football/496291-madden-nfl-12-rookie-ratings-top-ten-linebackers.html

Top 10 Rookie RB: http://www.operationsports.com/forums/madden-nfl-football/495637-madden-nfl-12-rookie-ratings-top-ten-running-backs.html

Top 10 Rookie DL:
http://www.operationsports.com/forums/madden-nfl-football/496295-madden-nfl-12-rookie-ratings-top-ten-defensive-linemen.html

Top 10 Rookie WR: http://www.operationsports.com/forums/madden-nfl-football/495920-madden-nfl-12-rookie-ratings-top-ten-wide-receivers.html


What really surprised me was the Linebackers and how Brooks Reed was only a 69 and that Von Miller didn't get a 80. The Defensive Line and WR ratings surprised me, I mean especially Da'Quan Bowers who got a 74 and Clayborn who got a 78, wow is Tampa going to be a good team to play with in Madden. Great to see that AJ Green & Julio Jones stand out compared to the rest of the receivers, but Greg Little has a better rating than Torrey Smith who was taken a pick after him?
[/quote]
Ya how the bleep is casey mathews a 71 overall and better than Brooks Reed? Mathews was a 4th round pick I believe. That is just ridiculous IMO.

[*kid_chaos100*]

Suprising J Smith is 76 overall....

2. Torrey Smith- 69
3. Jah Reid-70
4.Tandon Doss-65
5.Chykie Brown- 63
6.Tyrod Taylor-62
7.Phernell Mcphee-63
8.Anthony Allen-60

[jimmysmith3]

[quote name='*kid_chaos100*' timestamp='1313549680' post='753061']
Suprising J Smith is 76 overall....

2. Torrey Smith- 69
3. Jah Reid-70
4.Tandon Doss-65
5.Chykie Brown- 63
6.Tyrod Taylor-62
7.Phernell Mcphee-63
8.Anthony Allen-60
[/quote]
What do you think? I think they're fair. Jimmy will actually play a lot better than his 76 overall rating because his important traits are all around 90, but his awareness is 43 or something so he'll be very good at coverage and stuff but just extrememly unaware.

[Intercepted]

Can't wait to see the ratings jump up after our first game vs the Steelers

[y0unghustla]

Here are the complete ravens roster rating before they up date the rosters[url="http://espn.go.com/espn/thelife/videogames/madden12ratings/_/team/bal/id/33/baltimore-ravens"]http://espn.go.com/espn/thelife/videogames/madden12ratings/_/team/bal/id/33/baltimore-ravens[/url]

[Bltravens]

[quote name='*kid_chaos100*' timestamp='1313549680' post='753061']
Suprising J Smith is 76 overall....

2. Torrey Smith- 69
3. Jah Reid-70
4.Tandon Doss-65
5.Chykie Brown- 63
6.Tyrod Taylor-62
7.Phernell Mcphee-63
8.Anthony Allen-60
[/quote]
McPhee and JSmith's ratings will go up before the season starts are my predictions.

[jimmysmith3]

[quote name='Bltravens' timestamp='1313792433' post='756198']
McPhee and JSmith's ratings will go up before the season starts are my predictions.
[/quote]
Do they adjust the players ratings again before the game is released?

[Mt. Crushmore]

[quote name='jimmysmith3' timestamp='1313815932' post='757525']
Do they adjust the players ratings again before the game is released?
[/quote]
I don't think so but they might in the updated roster.

[Radinho84]

[quote name='y0unghustla' timestamp='1313768554' post='755864']
Here are the complete ravens roster rating before they up date the rosters[url="http://espn.go.com/espn/thelife/videogames/madden12ratings/_/team/bal/id/33/baltimore-ravens"]http://espn.go.com/e...altimore-ravens[/url]
[/quote]
ray lewis faster than all the other lbs is just laughable....
in general our offense is rated very bad...

[y0unghustla]

i think jimmy smith and ray rice speed should be higher