Top QB List In NFL

[purple.n.black]

[quote name='mgridda' timestamp='1305103507' post='684979']
Brady threw many short passes in almost a WCO where his primary duty was finding the open man and getting him the ball. He did that very well and is the #2 QB in the NFL, but he didn't have to deal with having as terrible an offensive line as Manning who only had 1 good player (Jeff Saturday) on that entire o-line and he didn't have to deal with losing Dallas Clark.

When Dallas got injured, Jacob Tamme led all receivers in targets afterwards. Manning had to make a lot of difficult throws, had worse receivers and had much less time in the pocket and got hurried and pressured multiple times more than Brady.

Peyton Manning is the best QB in the league.
[/quote]
Its too tough to really pick who is definitely better for me. But I don't think you can say that and ignore how Tom had to also deal with injuries, had to fit Woodhead into the offense, two rookie tight ends, and of course one of his favorite targets left in Moss.

[Guest RBates]

[quote name='mgridda' timestamp='1305098457' post='684969']
My list is pretty close to yours:

1. P. Manning
2. Brady
3. Rodgers
4. Brees
5. Rivers
6. Roethlisberger
-- DROP OFF --
7. Flacco
8. Vick
9. Ryan
10. Freeman
11. E. Manning
12. Romo
13. Schaub
-- DROP OFF --
14. Orton
15. Garrard
16. Bradford
17. Sanchez
18. Cassel
19. Kitna
20. Campbell
21. Stafford
22. Cutler
23. Hasselbeck
24. Ryan Fitzpatrick
25. Donavon McNabb
26. Carson Palmer
27. Shaun Hill
28. Kerry Collins
29. Colt McCoy
30. Vince Young
31. Brett Favre
32. Alex Smith
33. Chad Henne
34. Derek Anderson
35. Jimmy Clausen
[/quote]
Flacco over Vick with identical Numbers minus Vick's rushing of course, and Vick missed 4 games. Are you kidding me? lol

[PeRK82]

why in the world is Matt ryan and sam Bradford (of all people ) ranked higher than Flacco, i know he isnt the best but he is a imo a top 10. And for Bradford he should be around 15,16 maybe but in the top ten, give me one good reason, just one. and it better be a good reason and it still wouldnt hold up.

Screw the list, it junk. We will see how joe is ranked after this season or when Cam is gone, which every comes first (Cam being fired i hope first)

[BmoreRaised]

[quote name='RBates' timestamp='1304045456' post='673245']
lol just the tape
[/quote]
Vick had his chance against Green Bay and lost!Vick had a great season last year but lets look at him before he went to Philly? i think his highest career qb rating was 81 or 82 before this year?I think the offense around Vick made him more than vice versa.

Vick played top 10 this year for sure but overall career wise?lol

[Guest RBates]

[quote name='BmoreRaised' timestamp='1306078407' post='689373']
Vick had his chance against Green Bay and lost!Vick had a great season last year but lets look at him before he went to Philly? i think his highest career qb rating was 81 or 82 before this year?I think the offense around Vick made him more than vice versa.

Vick played top 10 this year for sure but overall career wise?lol
[/quote]
wow......interesting his football career is laughable? Yeah i can tell someone doesn't watch much football. Make sure you keep your eye on the guy that is getting Kevin Kolb traded: This year will be even better. Oh and by the way, he was a top 5 Qb this year and missed 4 games.....lol

[1/28/01]

[quote name='RBates' timestamp='1307087524' post='692855']
wow......interesting his football career is laughable? Yeah i can tell someone doesn't watch much football. Make sure you keep your eye on the guy that is getting Kevin Kolb traded: This year will be even better. Oh and by the way, he was a top 5 Qb this year and missed 4 games.....lol
[/quote]
Well, one way or the other, somone is being proven wrong. Only time will tell....lo (oh hell, I can't do it!)

[Gordo52]

Well I think Snachez should be higher. 2 afc chamionships in 2 years. Thats good for a young qb, just ask Joe. But anyway Top 10.....Overall Talent wise....
1-Manning
2-Brady
3-Rodgers
4-Vick
5-Brees
6-Rivers
7-Roethlisburger
8-Joe Flacco
9-Ryan
10-Romo

[da#1ravensfan]

1 Peyton Manning
2 Tom Brady
3 Drew Brees
4 Aaron Rodgers
5 Philip Rivers
6 Big Ben
7 Michael Vick
8 Eli Manning
9 Joe Flacco
10 Matt Ryan

[Corvus]

My objective top 15 (as of end of '10 season)
1 Aaron Rodgers
2 Tom Brady
3 Peyton Manning
4 Drew Brees
5 Ben Roethlisberger
6 Phillip Rivers
7 Matt Schaub
8 Michael Vick
9 Joe Flacco
10 Matt Ryan
11 Josh Freeman
12 Sam Bradford
13 Eli Manning
14 Mark Sanchez
15 Ryan Fitzpatrick

Tony Romo would be my 16th, he would be higher to me if his season hadn't ended so early

[atljbo]

[quote name='AwakenTheDemon' timestamp='1303523010' post='668893']
I've always loved how much love Ryan gets and how little Flacco gets (in comparison) when their stats are practically identical, and Flacco has playoff victories.
[/quote]


Not trying to be funny but this is a interesting stat.... I keep hearing ppl bring up the playoff wins but someone told me these interesting stats.


[quote]Well here are the two quarterback's playoff stats...

[b]Joe Flacco (7 starts):[/b] 98/184 53.2% 1,050 yards 4 touchdowns and 7 interceptions
[b]Matt Ryan (2 starts):[/b] 46/69 66.6% 385 yards 3 touchdowns and 4 interceptions
[/quote]


I give flacco props for his playoffs wins... Matt has to win a playoff game,... But you can easily say the playoff wins is more of a team thing.

I'm not taking anything from Flacco... I'm just saying.. That shouldnt be the defining thing on whose the better player.... Neither are overly good stats but Ryan playoff numbers are actually better then Flacco when you look at the games played aspect.


This debate will go on for years to come..lol