Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Samari

Best Player On Every Team

39 posts in this topic

Bolded all the ones that I disagree with, yikes!

ok well would you mind telling me who the hell is better in MIA than ronnie brown...big news thomas and taylor dont play there anymore

and who in gnb is better than donald driver

and who in buf is better than marshawn lynch

who in chicago would you take over alex brown

urlacher has declined

youve apparently not seen big al's impact

and shawn springs

and after seeing pat williams leave and they were gashed by seattle...and yet when AP leaves...chester taylor does great

casey hampton is what keeps the steelers run d in check...you cant possibly say ben or willie are better

ernest graham is better than you think

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ok maybe keith brooking

look at the impact bob has....ngata?great but seriously...not the among the best at his [profanity deleted]. like the others you listed

and stop with bradys SB rings....thats a team effort

tell me what WR wouldve done good in oakland

remember his minnesota days

Randy Moss is a great player, i agree. But you are crazy to say he is better than Brady..Not even close. For a player like Randy Moss to just quit on a team not just in Oakland, but if you remember him a couple times in Minnesota just walking off the field and going to the locker room before the game was over. He is a little cry baby.

Ngata, maybe not great yet I will agree. But i would put him above Mcgahee on our team as far as impact. Mcgahee is not in the top 5 on our team as far as talent if you ask me.

and who in gnb is better than donald driver

Ill take Al Harris, Aaron Kampman,KGB, over Donald driver.

and who in buf is better than marshawn lynch

Lee Evans, Jason Peters,Aaron Schobel,Donte Whitner..Lynch has only played 1 year in the league and had a slightly above average year with 1000 yards and 7 tds. No way he is the best on that team

DAL: MArion Barber..no way..Demarcus Ware, The hole offensive line, Terrel Owens??

Jets- David Harris..Brett Favre,Faneca,

Giants- Bradshaw..dont even need to say anything here do i??? Plex, Jacobs(the guy who is starting AHEAD of Bradshaw)

Pit- Casey Hampton- They are saying he may not even start because he is out of shape..even if he does hwo about Big Ben, Hines ward, Polamolu

SDG- Merriman is good, LT is amazing who will go down as a top 3 RB to ever play the game

TB- Ernest Grahm - If Cadillac was healthy this guy wouldn't even be starting..but he is the best on the team?? Joey Galloway, DERRICK BROOKS??

Not sure how you came to the conclusion on these players but 2 of the guys you have listed here arent even starters.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Randy Moss is a great player, i agree. But you are crazy to say he is better than Brady..Not even close. For a player like Randy Moss to just quit on a team not just in Oakland, but if you remember him a couple times in Minnesota just walking off the field and going to the locker room before the game was over. He is a little cry baby.

Ngata, maybe not great yet I will agree. But i would put him above Mcgahee on our team as far as impact. Mcgahee is not in the top 5 on our team as far as talent if you ask me.

Ill take Al Harris, Aaron Kampman,KGB, over Donald driver.

Lee Evans, Jason Peters,Aaron Schobel,Donte Whitner..Lynch has only played 1 year in the league and had a slightly above average year with 1000 yards and 7 tds. No way he is the best on that team

DAL: MArion Barber..no way..Demarcus Ware, The hole offensive line, Terrel Owens??

Jets- David Harris..Brett Favre,Faneca,

Giants- Bradshaw..dont even need to say anything here do i??? Plex, Jacobs(the guy who is starting AHEAD of Bradshaw)

Pit- Casey Hampton- They are saying he may not even start because he is out of shape..even if he does hwo about Big Ben, Hines ward, Polamolu

SDG- Merriman is good, LT is amazing who will go down as a top 3 RB to ever play the game

TB- Ernest Grahm - If Cadillac was healthy this guy wouldn't even be starting..but he is the best on the team?? Joey Galloway, DERRICK BROOKS??

Not sure how you came to the conclusion on these players but 2 of the guys you have listed here arent even starters.

after seeing bradshaw in the postseason i have to go with him

ok and graham is MUCH BETTER than cadillac...seriously...plz dont use caddy as an example

polamalu is the most overrated safety ever....and hampton is out of shape every year...and big ben....NO...i do hope they dont start casey hampton though...its better for us

DONTE WHITNER?are you out of your mind...dude...marshawn lynch draggs tacklers after contact all the time,dont pay too much attention to stats

KGB is a 1 dimensional player..did you see harris torched against TO and burress

LT is overrated....he was WAY TOO INCONSISTANT last year...and also...his o-line is a HUGE REASON for his success...playing here hed have a sub 4.0 average

and also...you underrate mcgahee very much

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Randy Moss is a great player, i agree. But you are crazy to say he is better than Brady..Not even close. For a player like Randy Moss to just quit on a team not just in Oakland, but if you remember him a couple times in Minnesota just walking off the field and going to the locker room before the game was over. He is a little cry baby.

and...if your talking about being a little crybaby

how about complanian tomlinson

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When you say better, I am going with someone who would be ranked higher in terms of individual skillset at their respective position.

and who in gnb is better than donald driver

Barnett, Harris

and who in buf is better than marshawn lynch

Peters, Evans

who in chicago would you take over alex brown

Hester, Harris

and shawn springs

Portis, Moss, Cooley, and others. Shawn Springs dude?

casey hampton is what keeps the steelers run d in check...you cant possibly say ben or willie are better

Palomalu, Ward

DAL: MArion Barber..no way..Demarcus Ware, The hole offensive line, Terrel Owens??

Jets- David Harris..Brett Favre,Faneca,

Giants- Bradshaw..dont even need to say anything here do i??? Plex, Jacobs(the guy who is starting AHEAD of Bradshaw)

Plus Osi Umenyiora. And if you want a glimpse of who their best player will be in the future; IMHO, Kenny Phillips

SDG- Merriman is good, LT is amazing who will go down as a top 3 RB to ever play the game

TB- Ernest Grahm - If Cadillac was healthy this guy wouldn't even be starting..but he is the best on the team?? Joey Galloway, DERRICK BROOKS??

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
after seeing bradshaw in the postseason i have to go with him

ok and graham is MUCH BETTER than cadillac...seriously...plz dont use caddy as an example

polamalu is the most overrated safety ever....and hampton is out of shape every year...and big ben....NO...i do hope they dont start casey hampton though...its better for us

DONTE WHITNER?are you out of your mind...dude...marshawn lynch draggs tacklers after contact all the time,dont pay too much attention to stats

KGB is a 1 dimensional player..did you see harris torched against TO and burress

LT is overrated....he was WAY TOO INCONSISTANT last year...and also...his o-line is a HUGE REASON for his success...playing here hed have a sub 4.0 average

and also...you underrate mcgahee very much

A guy plays good in a couple of games and you use that as your reasoning for naming him the best player on the team...If thats the case you could say Eli is the best.. Come on man, Bradshaw shouldn't even be in the same breath as OSI and plex

Cadiallac is overrated..ok thats fine, but he would still be the starting running back and he is better than ernest graham.

I would say Donte Whitner would qualify as a better player at his position than Marshawn would. And since we aren't paying much attention to stats Kyle boller may be the best on our team as far as potential..but dont look at his stats because his potential is what matters, forget about weather or not he produces on the field.

LT is overrated...wow cant believe i heard someone say that. He was "inconsistent" last year..so he automatically is not a good player?? He was the leading rusher in the league last year..scored 15 td, but he is inconsistent?? Please, you must not watch football. You can argue every running back to ever play the game is benefiting from a good OL. LT is a top 3 rb to ever play the game period. Good OL or not, he is one of the best to ever play. In 7 season he has 115 rushing TD's and you call that overrated?

Mcgahee has been playing for 5 seasons and he has a whopping 31 rushing TD's. Now lets talk about who is overrated.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
A guy plays good in a couple of games and you use that as your reasoning for naming him the best player on the team...If thats the case you could say Eli is the best.. Come on man, Bradshaw shouldn't even be in the same breath as OSI and plex

Cadiallac is overrated..ok thats fine, but he would still be the starting running back and he is better than ernest graham.

I would say Donte Whitner would qualify as a better player at his position than Marshawn would. And since we aren't paying much attention to stats Kyle boller may be the best on our team as far as potential..but dont look at his stats because his potential is what matters, forget about weather or not he produces on the field.

LT is overrated...wow cant believe i heard someone say that. He was "inconsistent" last year..so he automatically is not a good player?? He was the leading rusher in the league last year..scored 15 td, but he is inconsistent?? Please, you must not watch football. You can argue every running back to ever play the game is benefiting from a good OL. LT is a top 3 rb to ever play the game period. Good OL or not, he is one of the best to ever play. In 7 season he has 115 rushing TD's and you call that overrated?

Mcgahee has been playing for 5 seasons and he has a whopping 31 rushing TD's. Now lets talk about who is overrated.

its not potential or stats dude

stats NEVER tell the whole story...and stop with rushing TDs...their a situational stat..its not fantasy football....i never said LT sucked...its just that hes not among the "greatest ever" and certainly not as great as those morons on espn keep saying

our o-line sucked last year...even worse than 2006...j.lewis gets 3.6 a carry...you think hes done...and yet he goes to cleveland and does great...and mcgahee gets 4.1 here,which well is pretty good for the line and passing game we had last year

and come on...you dont see it with LT...over half of his games he didnt even have 4 yards per carry...but when you have 3 of the worst run ds in the nfl in your division it can *** your stats

you mustve missed mcgahee breaking all those tackles and marshawn taking defenders for a ride last year...he drove ray lewis for a ride i believe...whitner sucks dude...like you said its not potential

caddy is not better than ernest graham...you mustve missed ernest graham last year,how 3 guys would hit him and hed still fall forward...bradshaw too

ok so i will say hes not the best giant yet...but still...he will be great

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
its not potential or stats dude

stats NEVER tell the whole story...and stop with rushing TDs...their a situational stat..its not fantasy football....i never said LT sucked...its just that hes not among the "greatest ever" and certainly not as great as those morons on espn keep saying

our o-line sucked last year...even worse than 2006...j.lewis gets 3.6 a carry...you think hes done...and yet he goes to cleveland and does great...and mcgahee gets 4.1 here,which well is pretty good for the line and passing game we had last year

and come on...you dont see it with LT...over half of his games he didnt even have 4 yards per carry...but when you have 3 of the worst run ds in the nfl in your division it can *** your stats

you mustve missed mcgahee breaking all those tackles and marshawn taking defenders for a ride last year...he drove ray lewis for a ride i believe...whitner sucks dude...like you said its not potential

caddy is not better than ernest graham...you mustve missed ernest graham last year,how 3 guys would hit him and hed still fall forward...bradshaw too

ok so i will say hes not the best giant yet...but still...he will be great

LT 4.7 yards a carry over the season. You can say all you want..Mcgahee had bad games too im sure, as does every nfl player. LT will be viewed as a top 3-5 running back to ever play the game and for you not to see that shocks me. Can you please name the 5 running backs better than LT?

Mcgahee is good..not great. He has never even started every game of a season. His YPC last year were the highest he has ever had, which was 4.1..Other years were 3.8,3.8,4.0. All im trying to say is Mcgahee is not our best player, not even in the top 5 of our best players. You have a much higher opinion than most people do of him for whatever reason.

Im not doubting Lynch to be a good running back..im simply saying he is not the best player on the team. Same with Mcgahee, i believe he is a GOOD running back, but not even close to the best player on our team.

I will believe the hype about ernest grahm when he can duplicate what he did last year this year.He is a average back at best..all he does is run straight head, no juking no jiving, just a down hill runner..almost like a fullback

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
LT 4.7 yards a carry over the season. You can say all you want..Mcgahee had bad games too im sure, as does every nfl player. LT will be viewed as a top 3-5 running back to ever play the game and for you not to see that shocks me. Can you please name the 5 running backs better than LT?

Mcgahee is good..not great. He has never even started every game of a season. His YPC last year were the highest he has ever had, which was 4.1..Other years were 3.8,3.8,4.0. All im trying to say is Mcgahee is not our best player, not even in the top 5 of our best players. You have a much higher opinion than most people do of him for whatever reason.

Im not doubting Lynch to be a good running back..im simply saying he is not the best player on the team. Same with Mcgahee, i believe he is a GOOD running back, but not even close to the best player on our team.

I will believe the hype about ernest grahm when he can duplicate what he did last year this year.He is a average back at best..all he does is run straight head, no juking no jiving, just a down hill runner..almost like a fullback

running straight ahead is better...seriously...straight ahead runners are more consistant

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites