Trade Advice

[DieHardBMoreFan]

Got offered this and it made me think

i would be giving up
A. Peterson
MSW
M. Crabtree

I would be getting
Matt Forte
J. Flacco
B. Marshall

while im not 100% on that one, i was thinking of countering with

I give up
A. Rodgers
MSW
M. Crabtree

I would be getting
Thomas Jones
J. Flacco
B. Marshall


thoughts?

[AsianRice]

[quote name='DieHardBMoreFan' timestamp='1286662239' post='502523']
Got offered this and it made me think

i would be giving up
A. Peterson
MSW
M. Crabtree

I would be getting
Matt Forte
J. Flacco
B. Marshall

while im not 100% on that one, i was thinking of countering with

I give up
A. Rodgers
MSW
M. Crabtree

I would be getting
Thomas Jones
J. Flacco
B. Marshall


thoughts?
[/quote]
The second option is better because I think if QB can keep 15pts consistently is good and Flacco is getting better, Thomas and Peterson will be your best back.

[Clutch Ravens]

Honestly, I don't like either trade.

Flacco and Jones are both mediocre fantasy players and it's not worth giving up an elite QB or elite RB to get an elite WR.

[Ravensdiciple96]

Yeah I mean Marshall is a great WR and I got to be honest, I picked him up and have him on one of my teams. Now I have no clue if he will catch a little spark or what, but I also have Brandon Lloyd,Hakeem Nicks,(ala) Mark Clayton and of course the beast Antonio Gates as well and all of them have better points thus far of course. I'm am not saying Marshall is a pass over by any means, but like another said I wouldn't give up what you are willing to give up just to get him with a couple others.

[DieHardBMoreFan]

i didn't do either, thanks for the tips everyone

[Vademor]

Yeah, I wouldn't of done either of those either.

[reediddy]

[quote name='DieHardBMoreFan' timestamp='1286662239' post='502523']
Got offered this and it made me think

i would be giving up
A. Peterson
MSW
M. Crabtree

I would be getting
Matt Forte
J. Flacco
B. Marshall

while im not 100% on that one, i was thinking of countering with

I give up
A. Rodgers
MSW
M. Crabtree

I would be getting
Thomas Jones
J. Flacco
B. Marshall


thoughts?
[/quote]

The second trade is actually better, and considering that Rodgers is concussed plus his best target, Finley, is potentially out for the season, along with the multitude of options Flacco has to throw to, I'd probably take the second trade. Thomas Jones will get his TDs as a supplemental/goal line back, and B Marsh showed against the Jets that he is a top talent.

Plus, you aren't giving up much in terms of MSW and Crabtree, they aren't every-week options. Too inconsistent. Although, SF's new OC is dedicated to getting Crabtree the ball