I don't think "useless" is the term I used in regard to Upshaw, I just stated he was below average which by the stats and all the things you can actually measure is absolutely true. All of the negative comments on my posts just show how uninformed some posters are. He wasn't a good edge setter or run stuffer. A matter of fact I think Suggs is a better defender against the rush than Upshaw is. As many plays as he might make, he also got exposed and would over pursue and fail to set the edge. If you don't think so or don't know that, you don't watch games like I do. When I pointed out to whomever would read my posts for another sports related website this fact, Courtney Upshaw and a college buddy of his messaged me privately and in some colorful metaphors explained to me what they thought of my opinion. The very next day in a prominent city paper Mike Preston essentially quoted me on how Upshaw stunk up the place. I forwarded his post to Upshaw and his co-conspirator and never heard from them again. So, there's some class for you as well.
Just because a player is a Raven doesn't make him good. If you put him in another team's jersey instead of the Ravens, state he was a second round pick (our first pick in that year's draft by the way), you would come away thinking, "Boy, that team missed the mark."
They didn't draft Upshaw to be a single-task player that would simply stop the run from time to time. They drafted him with the intention for him to be the opposite side pass rusher of Suggs. So not only did that draft pick bust, but we had to sign Elvis Dumervil who costs us quite a bit of money in order to get the player Upshaw was expected to be. It was quite telling that the coach didn't even speak to Upshaw and didn't even know where he was when he was asked about the free agent. Translation: We're just not that in to him.
You don't use your first pick in the draft (again, he was a 2nd round pick, but he was our first pick in that particular draft because we traded down if memory serves) on a guy that can stop the run from time to time. You can find guys like that much lower in the draft. I have faith that somebody else on the roster can step up and be a rotational player on the defense and do just as well as Upshaw did.
I am a Ravens fan and support the team just like most of you do. I just don't allow my personal affection for the team get in the way of analysis. That's what a good journalist is supposed to do.