First thing's first, want to give a shout out to rmw10
He made the OP and the template here I used for my response to him.
Unrestricted FAs:
1. Kamar Aiken WR - GONE: I agree with the OP on some points, but I don't think he's better than the opportunity given to him this year, he simply wasn't the best option when everyone else is healthy.
2. Vladimir Ducasse OG - GONE: While he might be cheap he will still get a certain minimum for being a veteran and he was a street free agent signing for us. There's better talent out there and possibly cheaper and we might have some options in house like Broxton or Skura.
3. Matt Elam S - GONE: Dude has already had MORE than enough chances to prove he can hang and he didn't stay healthy and when he did play he was a train wreck. The ONLY reason he would stay is because somebody is trying to prove they didn't whiff on him. Useless player. Can't cover, can't tackle.
4. Lawrence Guy DE/DT - GONE: I like him for all the reasons the OP gave, but he will be due a raise and we've already got bodies behind him in Carl Davis, Timmy Jernigan, and Brent Urban.
5. Kyle Juszczyk FB - STAY: Nobody will value him like we do and I don't think his contract will break our bank.
6. Anthony Levine S/DB- GONE: Sure we like his versatility but he was hampered by toe injuries all season long. Versatile only wins you a job while you're cheap. Once you start costing money you're cut bait and the team will look to skew younger and possibly faster here.
7. Chris Lewis-Harris CB- STAY: Made some plays and held his own. He'll get a shot to stick because we're cutting a lot of other bait at this position.
8. Ryan Mallett QB - GONE: The walking headache inducer will have to ply his trade elsewhere and we'll look to pick up a veteran cast off on the cheap and hope and pray Joe never gets hurt.
9. Jerraud Powers CB - GONE: He was nothing special to begin with and proved he was nothing special here. Couldn't cover the slot and that's precisely why we got him. Buh-bye.
10. Rick Wagner OT - GONE: Somebody will pay him, we won't. We've got Alex Lewis waiting in the wings and the team loves him.
11. Brandon Williams NT/DT- GONE: For some reason DT's like Brandon Williams who make tackles and play against the run pretty well but don't record sacks got HUGE contracts last off season. By Brandon. They drafted your replacement three times over in Carl Davis, Willie Henry, and Micheal Pierce.
Restricted FAs:
1. Michael Campanaro WR/KR/PR - STAY: They'll take another chance on his health because of his potential to be that Wes Welker guy for us and he is right now the leading candidate for the return job unless Keenan Reynolds takes it away from him.
2. Marqueston Huff S - STAY: We're cutting bait with some of the older and underwhelming guys on this team. He's cheap and showed up a few times. Good enough.
3. James Hurst OT - GONE: He's gotten opportunities at both tackle positions and has looked absolutely horrible in just about every showing. He got Flacco's knee destroyed.
4. Ryan Jensen OG - GONE: Been around for a few years, looked okay at times, looked bad at times. Had a chance to start at G and the team decided to go with Vlad Ducasse. THAT tells you all you need to know.
5. Zach Orr MLB - STAY: Absolutely stay. You can pencil him in as a starter and you can always try to improve the position through the draft or with another FA signing, but he provided exactly what we needed along side of Mosley. A guy that can cover, make some turnovers, and he's not a turnstile against the run, but he could use a little beefing up.
6. Chris Matthews WR - GONE: Never did much of anything, was on IR all season. We're going in another direction.
7. Jumal Rolle DB - GONE: Hurt too often. Need to be healthy to stay on a roster.
8. Terrance West RB - STAY: Was the #1 until Dixon was healthy and then outperformed him in the second half. Still a good 1-2 punch. Needs to understand his role next season. Good back up plan if Dixon breaks down.
Cuts:
1. Kyle Arrington CB - Was terrible before he got hurt, now is hurt. Gone.
2. Elvis Dumervil OLB - There's a chance he might be back, but they'll restructure him if anything. We need talent here and he's got it if healthy.
3. Kendrick Lewis S - Gone. Useless player for us.
4. Dennis Pitta TE - He's not getting cut. He might take a pay cut, but no way the team is going to cut the only guy Flacco has any chemistry with at all.
5. Ben Watson TE - Luckily for us Pitta was healthy, but I liked the signing at the time. Now, we don't need him. We have younger and hopefully healthier talent.
6. Shareece Wright CB - I lamented at the time of his big contract that this was a half-year wonder that parlayed that into a big contract and then he came back down to reality. He's gone due to the emergence of Tavon Young. Team will still be looking elsewhere to revamp secondary.
Extensions:
1. Mike Wallace WR - I think some sort of negotiation is done here to free up some money. He may not be the Pittsburgh version of himself, but he has proven that at times he can make something out of nothing and can hit a home run. As long as we use him properly and don't depend on him as THE guy, we'll get good value out of him.
2. Lardarius Webb S - He was actually serviceable as a safety and performed about as well as I expected. There's a chance in another year at playing the position for the first time since his college days that he will be a bit better. Money is a factor, but also the fact that we have absolutely nothing waiting in the wings behind him is also a major factor.