polynesian15

I know, it sucks. He showed potential during those few flashes though. I would think this season is his last chance to make an impression. Fingers crossed for Mike, go out there and represent #15 (my lucky number)!

One word: Camp! Another word tho: health!

I guess I got carried away, over exaggerating to prove a point Then let's say the threshold is 800 yards - imo Perriman exceeds that with a clean bill of health. IMO you can't say he underperforms once again, with 650 yards, if he's out half the season with an injury. As I recall he had no injury concerns coming out of college - it's part of the game and happens to everybody. I will agree that we need to add some experienced depth (a Boldin type guy), and I'm convinced Ozzie is at work trying to make that happen as we speak. Torrey put up 1100 as he was the number 1 (only viable) target. Let's see what Perriman does in his first season as a starter.

I don't think I'm misjudging, but to each his own. I specifically stated that I like Torrey, and Boldin + Jacoby as well for that matter. I was merely comparing the talent level of the to receiver corps, and personally I don't think the SB cast was significantly more talented than the current one. That's where the discussion started. Add to that the FACT that Ozzie will add another weapon before the season - perhaps our old friend Anquan. Then I think this passing offense is ready to produce adequately along with a suffocating defense. However, this all depends on the line blocking, the running game becoming viable, and Joe's confidence and comfort level returning to pre-injury status. We are all aware of that. Are you aware that Torrey played his rookie season allowing him to gather yards in about 32 games? Did you know that Torrey was the only dependable WR other than Anquan (that's how despicable depth was back then compared to now imo) so he had a good amount of targets as the #2? More targets usually equals better production simply through more opportunity. Did you know that Torrey hasn't really had to deal with injury throughout his career, thus allowing him to hone his craft consistently without major setbacks? To your second point: rest assured, Ozzie will add another veteran presence to the WR corp. No need to worry about it 4 months from the season. Perriman will get a starting shot this season. If he stays healthy throughout the season yet underperforms in a mad way; say 20 rec/190 yards/1 TD, then I'll happily agree with your statements and worries. But I hardly doubt that's gonna happen, do you? In relation to player health and injuries: they just happen. You can only carry 53 players on the squad (and likely a max of 6 WRs) so how do you select your corp. Mediocre/aging players with no history of injury? And do you simply discard a player with immense potential and talent because he had a knee injury?

Yup, that's why I mentioned them. Think they'd be good fits. We probably can't afford both so if the FO is most concerned about RT they might target Dunlop. Vice versa if Center is most concerning Mangold would be the target obviously. That could be interesting, and he might come at a very reasonable price as you mention.

Because he got injured the first day of TC the year before and was sidelined much of TC the following year - i.e. he had to get up to speed, get reps in, get his footing etc. Don't get me wrong I like Torrey, and he was a valuable, if one sided, down field threat for us. But he always caught the ball in his belly, and he lacked physicality in a big way. Very seldom would you see him go up and out-muscle db's - cue that last play in the AFC championship vs NE. Perriman had his rookie season last year, and despite being used sparringly he displayed incredible feats we never saw from Torrey. You'll be smiling midway through next season when Perriman is balling. Sure injuries suck, but ALL players get hurt at some point - it's part of the game. Torrey had produced more, but he didn't miss an entire season. Don't know about the drops (anyone have statistics?), but I think most of Breshad's drops will vanish next season because he's getting settled in. Torrey was a starting receiver opposit Bolding because the rest of the cast consisted of Laquan, Doss, Reed etc. Perriman had to compete for targets against Smitty, Wallace and Aiken. You know Smitty and Wallace are the starters there, and Aiken proved productive on occasion - and again Perriman came off major injury. Not the case for Torrey.

That's an astonishing analysis - 841 is "better" than the 0 yards Perriman had his first year (due to injury) and the 499 yards he had his second year as 3rd/4th option. Numbers are one thing, actual play is another. Torrey hadn't dealt with season ending knee injury (to stunt his growth), and was also fortunate enough to participate in training camp. How many targets did Torrey and Breshad have their first (active) seasons respectively?

I'd have to agree here, kinda liked Tomlin until that move. Lost a lot of respect for him and his smug grin. But I still hate the Pats more - do you remember Brady's sliding tackle on Reed. Still infuriates me to this day - such a tart Tom is.

So you're saying Perriman should have gotten more yards from the bench his first year... or? In Torrey's third season he was pretty much the only pass option, kinda like when Aiken had a 1000 yards a couple seasons ago. I'm predicting an offense in which the ball is spread around with a healthy dose of rushing, in which Perriman still goes for more than a 1000 yards. You are saying worse than Torrey? I believe Perriman is 5x the player that Torrey is and will reach his 1000 yards way more effectively and without the force feeding. Besides that, Perriman is able to make those contested/agile catches that Torrey would never make. Better player, more impact. Pitta is still a good player in my eyes, now removed one year from his latest injury. I wouldn't compare Jones to Breshad, besides we're talking about Perriman THIS season not LAST season when he was the 3rd/4th option. Dixon/West/Woodhead will easily eclipse 500 yards from the backfield. Btw I'm not saying our current cast outshines the SB cast in every way. That was a championship caliber crew who played lights out during the post season and remained injury free to a large extent. What I'm saying is that the two casts aren't massively different from a talent perspective. We add a vet, Perriman develops, the line blocks and we run the ball. Team game.

Agree to disagree. -Torrey has nothing on Wallace. -Jacoby = Moore (speed and inconsistent hands - although Moore might have better routes). -Pitta is still Pitta in my eyes albeit a step slower. -Dickson basically never caught anything - so maybe a mix of Williams and Waller (that's probably being generous to Dickson). -Boldin never had elite numbers here, although he did provide toughness and clutch factor. Perriman will step up and Ozzie will add a vet. That leaves Camp and Gilmore, who when healthy have provided plenty of upside. We need 1 (vet) WR and we're good - be that Boldin, Marqise Lee or whoever Ozzie manages to acquire.

I'm not sure I would say Pitta was terrible last season, but he has obviously taken a step or two back because of injuries. I'd say he sort of filled the (physical) possesion-role last season with 86 rec for 729 yards. Not too shabby for an old guy with hip dysplasia or whatever it is. Ozzie has practically guaranteed that he'll add a WR in the coming months (hopefully OL as well). And I'm pretty sure Perriman will contribute. He was used very sparringly last season (started but 1 game), and still put up 33 rec, 500 yards and 3 TD's. He had some concentration drops when the ball was right on his number (jitters imo), but he showed incredible athleticism and body awareness. Came on at the end of the season. I see no reason why he wouldn't double his numbers. What's your take?

That might be enough, that's what we had during the last SB run. Do you think Boldin, Torrey, Jacoby Jones, Pitta and Ed Dickson are substantially better than Wallace, Perriman, Moore/Camp and Pitta/Williams/Gilmore? I don't. Besides,Oz adds at least 1 pass catcher before the season maybe more. Sure you can say "but injuries...". The fact is they are a part of the game, can't Perriman gets a starting role this season, with a full TC, and will do tremendously well: 70-80 rec, 1000-1100 yards, 6-8 TD's. He got rid of his rookie jitters last year and will make an impact this season imo. The keys are: (adequate) protection by the OL, for Flacco to gain more confidence post injury, and for the running game to become a consistent, viable threat again.

Good point, you can obviously get stronger without adding unnecessary weight. I'm excited about our new strength/performance coach. He seems more "sensible" and innovative than Bob Rogucki was. Alright, guess that's settled then. Let's go pre-season!

What would such a trade entail?

A vet OL is equally important. Perhaps Mangold or Dunlop depending on how they feel about Lewis as RT or Jensen/Urschel/Siragusa at C.