It would have been nice if the guy who found the ring received a reward for returning it to the owner. However, that's not what happened. The guy found the ring and he had no intention of giving it back to the owner but intended to keep it and profit from it. Since this was a newsworthy ring, this guy knew exactly who it belonged to and how upset she was. Perhaps he held on to it to have the publicity die down before he tried to sell it but he had 9 months for his conscience to kick in and rethink it that maybe he should return it to Toni. Certainly, within that 9 months, this guy had ample opportunity to research the law and find out that it was against the law for him to keep it and against the law for him to fail to come forward and inform her that he had the ring. Within that 9 months, either he knew he was breaking the law or should have known by then. At any time he could have looked inside the ring and found the name of the owner if he "forgot" and could have called the castle once he found out that he was breaking the law rather than keeping it anyway. Instead, this guy went to knowingly sell/trade a ring which did not belong to him. The fact that he turned white when Toni showed up says it all. So, I could see deserving or appreciating a reward if he returned it but even then, he still wouldn't be ENTITLED to a reward. Doing the right thing should be enough. I think he knew full well he was not legally entitled to keep the ring but tried to get away with it anyway. That's a dirtbag in my book.