You can debate it all you want, it doesn't mean those scouts are right. You also have to remember that these analyses come based off of college level talent and not pro level talent. He might be great at defending the run in college, but when he gets into the NFL where everyone is bigger, stronger, faster, he might not be as stout. Not only that, but we don't need a run stuffing OLB, we need a pass rusher. Our problem has also been coverage from our line backing crew and that is one of the weaknesses of Bosa. If you are going to trumpet what he does well and pay attention to that analysis, then you should put just as much stock into the negatives. What follows is a quip from NFL.COM:
" Bosa has a few more flaws than some may be willing to admit and his upside might be good rather than great, but his traits and growth potential as a player make him a safe selection. Bosa might be at his best with a defensive coordinator willing to move him around the field."
Bosa is too small to play DE in our scheme. He's not strong enough to play DE in our scheme either. So his versatility would only come at both OLB spots and in our defense they are our rushers. There is some debate about whether he'll be great. He doesn't have elite speed, doesn't have elite strength, has issues in coverage, doesn't fit our scheme, and will need to be "disguised" in order to get the most out of him. Oh, did I mention he has some character issues? No thanks.
Good stuff about Bosa , I like this kid, as defense is needed with all the F A signings for offense
