Well, he's not the best... that much is clear.
But he also doesn't have to be the best to get paid the best. Payscale is largely just a reflection of opportunity and timing.
It's not clear! It's certainly debatable and your argument is a good one especially after the year Tucker had. What if I told you Tucker was injured all year but didnt wanna attract attention or make excuses. Would that change your mind? If we debated this 6 months ago would you have an case against Tucker especially when you consider his age. Tucker had 3 seasons where he played at an all time great level. It was only this year that he missed quite a few here and there. Thus, making his all time numbers not so great because he's only been a pro for 4 years. His celing is certainly as good as if not higher than gostkowski. I personally don't see him falling outside of the best 5 kickers in the NFL at any given year in the near future. Honestly, a little bit of me was happey that he missed a few because had he not, his agent would be asking for the richest kicker contract ever. Now we have a better chance of keeping Tuck for years to come and I'm beyond satisfied. I also don't remember the last time anyone returned a kickoff against us for a TD. That's mostly because of Tuck.