You guys are understimating Peter's value. He's been one of the most solid and spectacular Left Tackles of this decade. Sure he's declining and had a tough year, and sure his 8 stars might be hefty but I'll take a chance and be optimistic he rebounds this year. At worst he's got a serviceable 2-3 years left.
Sure this might be a good left tackle class but look at how left tackles in the first round in recent years have performed. Joeckle, Fisher, Matthews... Would rather take a veteran then rely on an unproven rookie