Idk, because I'm also not sold on the fact that we would have made him the highest paid RT. He really doesn't fit the new litmus test of "big and strong" and Ozzie and Harbaugh have talked about. I'm of the belief that right tackles are only worth investing in if they are straight violent blockers that bring the pain. There is zero nastiness to his game. Looking back, we've tended to prefer the nastier guys. Urschel and Wagner aside, the vast majority of our offensive line picks have been brawlers, and Urschel was nasty in college tbh. Don't know where that went.
Wagner's as good a pass protector as you can ask for at RT, but there's nothing else to his game at all. He's not good on screens, he can't seal on stretch, and he can't pummel his man in short yardage. That's not worthy of top RT money if you ask me. Top RTs, to me, are guys like Bulaga and Vollmer, who smash heads every play.