I agree he is a spectacular player, but he has not even hit his prime. His prime will be when he wins the big games. When he leads his team to the super bowl once or twice (note that I said "when", not "if") he will be widely respected as one of the best. But for now, I don't think he compares to Brady, Manning, or Brees. Flacco has an edge on him because of his playoff skill. His clutch factor is off the charts. But Luck has a very bright future, and had he been there at number 3, I would've taken him no doubt.