Personally I think Weddle is overrated... Plus he is a lot older. For a FS, he's not as athletic as I would hope, and he doesn't have a nose for the football like Earl Thomas. Earl Thomas is the jewel in the crown of the Seahawks secondary. On the other hand, Earl Thomas has one hell of a supporting cast, and Weddle has pretty much been the only superstar in the San Diego secondary for a while (minus one guy this year), so you have to respect him for that.