We're not addressing players having bad or good years here though. Which I don't doubt happens to them one bit. But, we're talking about a "specific" season. One in which involves an athlete being on the Madden Cover.
Now, once again, I don't personally believe in curses but stated that those who were on the Madden Cover and got injured "that particular season" after being on the MC was an "eerie coincidence" did I not?
My rebuttal, to your statement in the previous post......which I also substantiated with links.....was that; while a mere handful of players who were on the Madden Cover did play well or avoided a injury, "the majority" of them succumbed to some kind of injury or low production that particular season "after" being on the Madden Cover.
That happens to be a known fact regardless as to whether or not myself, you or the injured player themselves choose not to believe in or not to call it a curse. To say that the so-called curse was selective? I wouldn't know about that cause agan, I don't believe in curses. That maybe a question for one of those injured athletes to answer.