Its a rare day in Baltimore when I agree with you but I think today's the day! In the above novel, I think you just acknowledged that Joe's competent. That's a step up from most of the intellectual giants who have posted less complimentary things about Joe on this forum. Most of them wouldn't know the difference between competent and elite if Joe's career or personal life depended on it. I'm not sure what your definition of either is but you have intimated that there are less than 32 competent QBs in the NFL. If that is true, your list of elite QBs must really be small. I would suggest Joe's in the 2nd tier of QBs in the league in terms of his overall performance right now. I would also suggest that he's both competent and elite for a variety of reasons, which I do not care to expound upon. Of course, there must be a basis to make such a preposterous claim as this. So, please indulge me. It is simply this. In the NFL, there are only a handful of QBs who I would consider "Triple A" QBs. The shortlist would include those QBs with Athleticism, Arm strength and Accuracy. AND, if there were a fourth A, it would be Attitude. No matter how you rate him in the four "A" categories, Joe is competent and elite. Unfortunately, he's playing on a team that is neither competent nor elite in many ways, not the least of which is the coaching. If Coach Harbaugh learned anything from an earlier game in which we called a pass on 1st and goal to go, it didn't show up in the Cincy game, did it? At a point in the game when the score was 17-3, he opted to throw the ball to Pitta in the endzone again instead of running the ball. It was extremely poor coaching, playcalling and clock management, not to mention a poor read by Joe. Dixon was open in the flat for a certain TD and could have walked into the endzone but that's beside the point. If Joe is ever gonna play at a higher level, the coaching philosophy of this team and its culture must undergo some immediate changes. It was Einstein who once said "the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results." He also said "You have to learn the rules of the game. And then you have to play better than anybody else." Its becoming patently obvious that our Head Coach is no Einstein and its also apparent that you don't have to be a football player to be a good coach. Golly, I suppose an aeronautical engineer from Renssalear Polytechnical Institute could even learn how to be a pretty good football coach, huh?