I'm with my friend right now (Bengals) and we were just talking about how Pittsburgh took out Palmer in that playoff game during their run. I can't give him credit for 2005, the best pass thrown by a Steeler that game was Antwan Randaell.
You're right that we all point to Flacco's playoff success to defend him, but he has played very well and won games, hey Flacco has a SB MVP Ben doesn't have one
like I said, I'd be fine if he was our QB, now Dalton, no way, I'll take his line, RBs, WR and TE though.
I like his ability to extend plays and that certainly is eye test driven.