I still don't have a problem with Tillman starting this game. I think Buck is a great manager, but what killed me is not putting Britton in once Ubaldo gave up the two hits. Totally stupid and I do think he was "saving" him for when we got a lead. That doesn't work when it is a one game playoff. Don't get me started on Reimhold either. His defense made a huge difference that inning.
At the end of the day though, it was our totally undisciplined bats that did us in. How many struck out swinging at a stupid ball in the dirt? When you have the leaders on this team doing that on a regular basis (yes I'm looking at you Adam!), you are not going anywhere in the playoffs. I'm totally crushed we didn't make it farther but at least we had a chance.