Agreed to an extent.
You can put me in the camp that thinks Timmy is overrated by some, but I still don't like the move. You can compare Pierce all you want but I don't think that's a comparison at all because Pierce is largely not going to be on the field in true nickel situations. They both play DL but different roles.
The reason I don't like seeing Timmy gone is because he was arguably our best pass rusher, even compared to the edge guys we have. Sure, he was inconsistent but I didn't see anyone else out there doing any better. We just made an already anemic pass rush much worse and that's where the concern is.
Maybe we do only have him for 1 more year but I'd much rather have his production for that time than a jump in the 3rd round. 99 to 74 is a nice jump on paper but in my eyes, it just created yet another hole after not really filling any to this point. It's a nice draft class to have high picks but still, nothing is ever a sure thing. My problem is honestly more of the organizational philosophy this offseason where we're seemingly going to count on a bunch of young guys. I'm alright with asking guys to step up but there's a line and I think we're expecting too much. It looks like there's going to be a heavy reliance on having a killer draft and I just don't find that realistic. Hitting on all 4 picks, no matter how early and how deep, is a big ask.
Maybe Timmy sucks and we win the trade and maybe he's awesome in Philly and we lost it. I just don't see the value in this move as I don't believe we have a viable option currently on the roster.