2013: I never said KLM and Anthony were busts, I said they were "late round flyers who did not pan out"
2012: If Upshaw was solid, they would've re-signed him as he was cheap to keep. He was decent at setting the edge, not great at it. And was below average at everything else: pass rushing, tackles for losses, coverage, etc. He is JAG, an OK starter, but nothing really special. Basically replacement level.
2011: So...you agree with me on Jimmy and Pernell? Since you pretty much elaborated on what I said about them. My point with Pernell being that after showing such promise as a rookie, he was underused until his 4th and final year here. You can't expect to build a decent defense when you only get one good and one great year from one of the scant few good healthy players you draft on defense before that good player leaves. And I didn't say I expected Chykie to ever be anything other than a nickel or dime CB, at best. What I said was he was a "project they invested too much time in" meaning that once it became clear he'd reached his ceiling after showing no improvement after 2 seasons, it was time to move on and try to develop someone else. Instead, they kept him for another two years.
2009: So how come when he shed the weight and switched back to OLB, Kruger became productive? You wouldn't want that productivity for 3 or 4 years, you're willing to settle for one year because it happened to be the year we won the SB? And what if Kruger had been just as productive in 2011 or 2010, maybe...we would've won another SB or two? And where did I say anything about overpaying him like the Browns did.
2008: I acknowledged that Zibby and Haruki were excellent backup and ST guys. And yes, it would be nice if we did nab a Pro Bowler in the 4h or 5th round every once in awhile. That's not an unrealistic expectation. In fact, the better teams in the NFL do just that (and we actually have with guys like Arthur Jones and McPhee, so I don't even know why you're raising this point.)
2007: Yeah, he was. For San Diego who we traded Barnes to for a 7th round pick. He was only a Raven for 3 years where we got 5 sacks from him. With San Diego, he had 11 sacks in just one year. You really want to argue that we got the better end of that deal?
2006: So, we're just going to ignore what I said about Ngata, Landry and Martin. Likewise, we're going to dismiss what I said later about the 2006 draft being one of our defensive cornerstone drafts.
My overall point is that many of these have been good players, even a few great ones, but either they kept (or keep) getting hurt or we misuse or underuse them until they've got one foot out the door. And that's why when Ray, Ed & Haloti were gone and Suggs started showing his age, our defense fell back into mediocrity. Hopefully, though these last 2 drafts will begin to turn that back around.