@ellicottraven - I wanted to just hit the original point of the post. It has morphed a little into draft approach (BPA v. need, etc) and I want to speak to grading Ozzie on this drafts since 2011 and whether his draft magic is fantasy or reality.
Two things I think are flawed with how you laid out the information to use in evaluating performance in the draft:
We are talking about grading the draft - not grading how well the team managed cap in order to retain quality players taken. Discounting those no longer on the team is not a valid way to view how well a GM drafted.
Is the question how well Ozzie drafted in the early rounds, or is it how well he drafted overall? Cutting it off at round 4 isn't a full evaluation. I also believe the signing of undrafted players is a part of the overall draft process and should be a part of the evaluation as well.
If you account for those points above, you can include a number of notable players that you discounted - such as KO, McPhee, Wagner, Tucker and Orr.
All that said ... I don't think you will find anyone, not even Ozzie himself, to say that draft performance over these years has been up to our standards. In the view of the rest of the league, I'd say performance grades out at about a C over this span of time. IMO his draft magic was a reality, but he's been living off his reputation over the recent years. I have to think from the ownership standpoint, that we absolutely need to start seeing better results. I'm just not sure what the "or else" is if it doesn't improve.