This is a video I stumbled upon that talks about how the NFL could be improved (start watching at 6:45 to see where the NFL talk actually starts) which is why I started thinking about the subject. It's a podcast so there's a lot of random junk scattered in between NFL talks. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1RNRNiEQeOY
They propose kicking up the roster size to 60 or so players with no rules as to how many you can dress (which I am in support of), boosting the season to around 20 weeks with 2 byes and introducing a sort of minor league. They also exercise Harbaugh's and Tuck's idea of getting points from kickoffs, and talk about ways to make the extra point more exciting.
Boosting the roster size would help out to have more of a rotation with players and teams wouldn't have to cut down in one position in order to pad another (for instance, having only 2 QBs to have an extra RB). Also limiting how many players you're allowed to dress in a game doesn't make any sense to me.
Kicking up the season length and adding a bye I don't see the problem with. They proposed converting 2 of the preseason games into regular season games to make the regular season 18 games. Sure it would make season/career stats have to come with an asterisk because players would be playing more games than before, but that's easy to account for. Maybe we could see less commercials in games because of the NFL getting more advertisements in this way, and maybe add a few minutes to half time to further reduce the amount of commercials we see between drives and such. If we introduce minors that's even more revenue, therefore even less commercials hopefully.
A minor league would give players like UDFAs a chance to prove themselves and also give them game experience against NFL-worthy talent. This also gives us more football, which I don't think anybody is against. The NFL could also benefit from them by testing out rules in the minors and sending down refs as a punishment if they have abysmal games. Every NFL team would have their own minor team in their state or an adjacent one. The minors could maybe even play in the spring (it might be better to have the season run alongside NFLs regular season to allow for teams to pull players out when they need them), and I'd love to barely spend any money to see our next big prospects play a game. I see this as an improvement to the practice squad, giving us more players and a more meaningful, competitive experience. We can also pull any players out of the minors rather than just having 10 that we picked, so if we like what we see in a QB we might not need him but he could be a good backup.
The extra point is the most boring play in sports, maybe a mandatory 2 point conversion should be considered. The guys talk about maybe having an option to kick from a few yards closer to the opposite goalpost instead of going for two, and having a touchback go back to maybe the 15 or so yard line to further reward booting the ball as far as you can. Also maybe give returners the option to slide instead of giving their bodies up on a return so we can see teams run it out more instead of just kneeling it to guarantee the 25 yard line, and injuries would be less likely with the slide option.
Just posting to have a conversation about it and see if there's anything I'm missing with yall's opinions. I've really only thought about it while posting, so if I'm mistaken in seeing this as a good thing I'd like to know where I'm wrong.