This is a tough subject. Honestly JoeyFlex I think you should think about it this way, A) he might be gone by our pick, so no need to worry about being torn about it. Ever since the senior bowl and the combine his stock has risen faster than steam in a sauna. He has been constantly mocked inside the top 12. I personally think he's elevated himself into that top tier of prospects along with Hooker, Adams, Fournette, Garret, Lattimore etc...
And I love O.J. Howard. He can block which seems to be a concern Ravens FO has for tight ends (minus the pitta Dickson experiment), he can run (that much is certain about him), he has an A++++ character (never got the ball, never complained), and if he does get the ball he can make explosive plays with it that are worth at least 40 yards. This would cause defenses to account for him and could open up other players. He loves the seam route and so does Flacco. All of this makes me want O.J. especially since, as already stated, he's the best tight end prospect to come out in such a long time. On top of all of this the NFL is a match up league and O.J. Howard can be an asset as a blocker, he can indeed do the juszyk role in the backfield and get the ball much easier, he should outrun just about all linebackers so if he's covered by a linebacker because safeties fear our speed at WR then he wins that match up. Your fear is if he's covered by a safety and it's a tight window can he go up and get it? Personally, unless it's Kam Chancellor covering him, I think the only way he can't at least draw a PI call is if he trips over himself.
The case against O.J.? Unproven, I agree, we have plenty of "talent" at the position, I somewhat agree. These are the only points against O.J. let's look at them
1) the talent we have at TE is, besides pitta and to an extent Gilmore, also unproven. Waller is still working on it (I think he could be good), Boyle is one more failed drug test away from being kicked off the team or being suspended for another year, Maxx was popular but hasn't seen the field. I think there's lots of potential here, but since both O.J. and our group are really unproven you have to look at ceilings and O.J. has a higher one.
2) O.J. being unproven is impossible to refute and that certainly adds to the mystery of the boom or bust idea of him. But I will say this, with McCarron and Coker they actually occasionaly found O.J. when he was covered and he can make solid catches while carrying a defender, although with a limited sample size.
Long post I know, in the end I think if he's the BPA when we pick plus the depth of pass rushers and corners in this draft you take him