The reality is if Joe played like a Pro Bowler in the regular season and plays like Joe does in the playoffs, he would be one of the best players in the league. I think that is asking a bit much. His durability, however, is under appreciated as we have been quite fortunate to have him play 10 years and he has missed only a handful of games.
I think the mistake is that we are wanting and expecting him to be THAT type of quarterback, when he just doesn't have the IQ and accuracy to be THAT QB. Based on his skill set, it is better to surround him with a dominating OL and superstar RB, and less importantly though still necessary with guys who can stretch the field. We just need player's who can stretch the field to keep defence off balance. We then have to add guys who can break the game open from the backfield and the slot with YAC (i.e. a RB who can break it open (i.e. Dalvin Cook).
Although I am optimistic with Perriman, we have had a horrendous history of drafting WR's. Our WR scouting department needs to really be reviewed. The Steelers on the other hand have had great success picking guys who can stretch the field without paying them much. They know how to scout their WR's.
In an ideal situation for the offence, we cut Pitta post June to create cap space to re-sign Wagner. Dalvin Cook drops to 16 in the 2017 NFL draft or we trade up to get him. Adoree Jackson drops to round 2 and we pick him and put him the slot. B. Watson gets healthy and comes back as our receiving TE to replace Pitta and be a downfield threat.
We tender RFA T. West with original tender and someone picks him up giving us an additional 3rd rounder.
We then use our three 3rd round picks and 4th round picks to address Center, Cornerback, Guard.
So then we surround Joe with Wallace and Perriman on the outside, with Dalvin Cook/Dixon in the backfield, and Adoree Jackson in the slot. (We drafted Wagner with a 5 round pick, so if we can get an upgrade a Center w/ Zuttah as a restructured backup). Then we have B.Watson who can stretch the field and lead our young TEs (and cheap) into the future.
Then we accept our defence will be a Top 10 -15 with minor upgrades and hope any combination of Correa, Kaufusi, Davis, Henry can contribute next year. But we then get a better offence and running game that will dominate Time of Possession and help our defence out.
Rather than expect Flacco to play up to his salary and pull an Aaron Rodgers, I think this would best provide Flacco with an environment for success. One that would counter his inherent deficiencies and allow us to get to the playoffs where he plays his best.